Re: A new math usenet group

Herman Jurjus wrote:
My fear is that we'll end up with a junk group and a pedant group (and
basically no other math groups).


Bart Goddard wrote:
Right now, all we have is a junk group. So even if we add a pedant group,
it's an improvement. But I think you have no worry here. The only
way sci.math.moderated will turn sci.math into pure junk, is if it's
successful. And it won't be successful if it's a pedant group.

Sci.math is not a completely junk group. The fact that you and
other math-worthy posters are here is proof of that.

That being said, it is undeniable that sci.math has an unacceptably
large percentage of nonsense, troll postings, and spam.

Most of my enjoyment of sci.math is learning about math
(as I am only an amateur mathematician) by reading the interplay
between those in the know and those not. This includes the
more interesting banter posts provided by the totally clueless
cranks - but only the interesting and polite ones, a minority.

Of late I find absolutely no interest in the likes of James Harris,
Archimedes Plutonium, et al, and most especially Musatov (who
almost single-handedly has prompted this serious attempt at forming
a moderated math newsgroup). It's bad enough that it's just clutter,
but it's real sin is that it's just dull and boring.

So what I'm saying is that while I would certainly not miss
most of the garbage and nonsense currently littering sci.math,
I would in fact miss some of the, um, cream of the nonsense,
for the entertainment value as well as the educational value
(from the reasoned retorts). I worry that a pedant-only newsgroup
would be simply boring by comparison.

-drt
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: No blood for oil
    ... an additional 2% from the payroll taxes. ... It is just the math that makes me worry. ... Fleabaggers don't realize that if you print/create new inflationary debt dollars faster than Americans consume sheets of toilet paper, eventually toilet paper will have more value. ...
    (rec.boats)
  • Re: Long threads, tactics
    ... > of an electronic math journal. ... Your life is a lie. ... Do you believe anyone will ever accept your flawed nonsense? ... Chosen One" who brought the mathematical community out of it's second Dark ...
    (sci.math)
  • Re: First Weekend in April Time Wasting Thread
    ... your garden-variety math genius but a *musical* math genius. ... whatever the visual equivalent of white noise would be. ... (Okay, boring, boring, boring -- but I'm weird.) ... synesthesia, but not for numbers. ...
    (alt.fan.letterman)
  • Re: No blood for oil
    ... It is just the math that makes me worry. ... What a better way to destroy USA, from the inside with "In Debt We ... dollars faster than Americans consume sheets of toilet paper, ...
    (rec.boats)
  • Re: Quantum physics says goodbye to reality ["hidden variables"]
    ... It is not a good idea to try to understand nonsense. ... The math we did in school for that, many years ago, and any 5 year old can do. ... the butts of American jokes, Belgians the butts of Polish jokes. ...
    (sci.physics)