Re: Dental Records



Steve wrote:

Both technically and legally, you are paying for the diagnosis and
clinical judgement. You are not paying for the physical records, and as
far as I can tell this has always been the case legally.
___________________________________


Yes, it always has been the case legally.

Some folks may be surprised to learn that within living memory, some
dentists didn't keep clinical records.

In the early part of the 20th Century it was common for some dentists
to see all patients on a walk-in basis. Treatment was rendered, paid
for, and that was that. Neither the dentist nor the patient had any
need to write anything down -- so no records were kept.

The whole transaction was akin to buying a loaf of bread at the
baker's. Who needed to keep records of that?

I can recall older dentists who told me years ago that this was true,
in a diminishing number of cases, up to the 1940's. By then, of course,
all the younger, "modern" dentists were keeping some sort of records on
all patients.

Some of those records were really nothing more than a small note of
what treatment was rendered, and the amount paid by the patient. Back
in the 1970's, I worked for a dentist who had been in practice since
1947. His "records" for each patient consisted of a single 3 x 5 card,
which listed the date and abbreviated type of treatment for each visit.
Some of his patients' total records had 20 years of visits on ONE
LITTLE CARD. A typical entry would be : "3-15-57 #3 ext. $15."
Imagine!

Obviously the dentist created the record to keep the accounts straight
in his memory. The dentist doesn't own the patient's checkbook register
when a patient writes in it, and the patient doesn't own the dentist's
record when he writes in it. That is the way it has always been.

- dentaldoc

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: How Many Dentists Here Have Been Sued For Malpractise?
    ... The case was treated with implants because the patient refused to ... All these revisions kept the dentists in cash flow, but the patient ... could never be satisfied with the esthetics of ANY treatment. ...
    (sci.med.dentistry)
  • getting your dental records
    ... I'm aware that some dentists discourage this ... if the patient insists on having them. ... Joel M. Eichen,. ... and the new doctor can request x-rays. ...
    (sci.med.dentistry)
  • Re: Senator asks for stop to Govt control of amalgam studies
    ... Remeber that my dentist- Bob Marko left practice in 1992/1993 ... > HIV status. ... I think it is very risky to even ask a patient ... I agree that it is unfair to dentists. ...
    (sci.med.dentistry)
  • Re: should I sue the dental clinic
    ... that from the treatment plan and many times it may be a mistake. ... On occasion when I see that a patient despite their economic situation ... The reason dentists want to maintain malpractice insurance is for the ... would never be my dentist (I couldn't afford you) and I wouldn't be ...
    (sci.med.dentistry)
  • Re: Dental malpractice (UK) - Some questions - mostly legal
    ... composites right on top of pulp exposures with caries still present. ... this patient is probably the easiest patient I have ever worked on. ... > treatment done. ... > dentists, the UK also has many bad lawyers. ...
    (sci.med.dentistry)