Probe of FDA Breast Implant Plans Sought



SF Gate www.sfgate.com Return to regular view Probe of
FDA Breast Implant Plans Sought
-
Wednesday, August 10, 2005

(08-10) 06:18 PDT WASHINGTON, (AP) --

Consumer advocates asked Congress Tuesday to investigate the Food and
Drug Administration's plans to return silicone gel-filled breast
implants to the market, contending the agency is violating its own
safety standards.

Last year, the FDA told implant manufacturers to provide long-term data
on the durability of implants prone to breaking and on the consequences
of silicone leaking into women's bodies if they wanted to lift a
decade-plus near-ban of the devices.

But last month, the FDA said it would approve Mentor Corp.'s implants
if the company met certain conditions - not publicly disclosed -
even though Mentor's main study tracked implant recipients for only
three years.

While implants have largely been exonerated of causing serious or
chronic illnesses, broken ones require surgical removal or replacement;
infection and painful, rocklike scarring also are side effects.

Also Tuesday, the National Organization for Women and a dozen other
women's and health groups urged FDA to release findings of its criminal
investigation of Mentor in the late 1990s, to settle concern that
implant problems were hidden.

The FDA closed that probe without taking any action against Mentor,
which has denied underreporting problems.

FDA's scientific advisers recommended approval of Mentor's implants in
April, and agency spokeswoman Julie Zawisza said the 2004 advice to
manufacturers wasn't mandatory. As for the Mentor probe, some of FDA's
findings are releasable and the agency is processing requests for it,
she said.


URL:
http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/n/a/2005/08/09/national/w133420D36.DTL

.



Relevant Pages

  • NOW: Uninformed Choice is No Choice at All
    ... Drug Administration (FDA) decision to send an approvable letter ... company that makes these implants, to the role of a senior manager at ... decision to issue Mentor Corporation an approvable letter to market ... were not sufficient to demonstrate long-term safety of their product. ...
    (talk.politics.medicine)
  • Controversial Implants Approved
    ... breast implants and issued a letter of approval to Mentor Corp ... they realise the risks of a silicone breast implant including the fact ... Mentor is only allowed to sell silicone breast implants to board- ...
    (rec.arts.sf.written)
  • Controversial Implants Approved
    ... breast implants and issued a letter of approval to Mentor Corp ... they realise the risks of a silicone breast implant including the fact ... Mentor is only allowed to sell silicone breast implants to board- ...
    (soc.men)
  • Controversial Implants Approved
    ... breast implants and issued a letter of approval to Mentor Corp ... they realise the risks of a silicone breast implant including the fact ... Mentor is only allowed to sell silicone breast implants to board- ...
    (rec.music.opera)
  • Controversial Implants Approved
    ... breast implants and issued a letter of approval to Mentor Corp ... they realise the risks of a silicone breast implant including the fact ... Mentor is only allowed to sell silicone breast implants to board- ...
    (alt.politics.bush)