Re: Campaign launched against dietary supplements

From: Anth (anon_at_anon.com)
Date: 01/31/05 

Date: Mon, 31 Jan 2005 06:58:15 -0000

Well first of all you called him a fraud while pushing your thalidomide
'cure' for mm. (and again later on)
You have no evidence that he's a fraud, he's doing research to see if the
therapy works, so you explain how scientific research is fraud?
Anth

"Mark Probert" <Mark Probert@lumbercartel.com> wrote in message
news:kO6Ld.4770$kU3.1801@fe08.lga...
>
> "Anth" <anon@anon.com> wrote in message
> news:41fc5892$0$120$65c69314@mercury.nildram.net...
>> Well you are your ilk are responsible for causing doctors problems,
>
> My "ILK"? Sounds like an ad hominem directed at me....
>
> Now, I asked you (see below) to tel lme what sort of problems I am causing
> these doctors. You meerely rephrased the statement without listing them.
>
> with
>> your flawed arguments and ad hominems.
>
> Asking that they proved their claims is NOT an ad hominem. Pointing out
> that
> they went from initial idea directly to selling is not an ad hominem,
> merely
> pointing out that they are having their customers...errr...guinea
> pigs....errr...customers...finance the testing for them. My arguments are
> far from flawed.
>
>> What reason have you possibly got for attacking Dr Gonzalez who is trying
> to
>> do real science with a therapy he believes is worthy of merit?.
>
> Fraud revolts me.
>
>> Anth

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Campaign launched against dietary supplements
    ... You have no evidence that he's a fraud, he's doing research to see if the ... >> Well you are your ilk are responsible for causing doctors problems, ... > Asking that they proved their claims is NOT an ad hominem. ... > pointing out that they are having their customers...errr...guinea ...
    (sci.med)
  • Re: May sound silly, but then it isnt my theory.
    ... will consist of ad hominem only? ... sign of a fraud. ... David A. Smith ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: May sound silly, but then it isnt my theory.
    ... crowd will consist of ad hominem only? ... Sure sign of a fraud. ... You - like so many others - seem to suffer under the delusion that the ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Campaign launched against dietary supplements
    ... Maybe his mother called him an idiot. ... > You have no evidence that he's a fraud, he's doing research to see if the ... so you explain how scientific research is fraud? ... >> Asking that they proved their claims is NOT an ad hominem. ...
    (sci.med)
  • Re: Campaign launched against dietary supplements
    ... Maybe his mother called him an idiot. ... > You have no evidence that he's a fraud, he's doing research to see if the ... so you explain how scientific research is fraud? ... >> Asking that they proved their claims is NOT an ad hominem. ...
    (sci.med.nutrition)