Re: The China Study

I have heard Campbell speak and yes, he is very convincing.
Unfortunately he is also caught up in this vegetarian propaganda. :o(

You mention the Seven Countries Study. Unfortunately for that study it
is flawed. There are many countries left out of the study that would
prove Key's theory incorrect or at least inconclusive.

There are many so-called health concerned people that feel that an
unnatural, low-fat, plant-based diet is the way to go. Unfortunately,
this low-fat myth is based upon studies that supposedly show a
diet/heart link. When you look at the data you will wonder how this
link has managed to last this long.

rr


On Mon, 4 Apr 2005 15:10:11 +0300, "Juhana Harju"
<shantigiri@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:

>Roger Rabbit wrote:
>:: On 2 Apr 2005 10:47:59 -0800, "Bawl" <bunghole-jonnie@xxxxxxxxx>
>:: wrote:
>::
>::: The China Study
>::: [...]
>::: "So, what is the prescription for good health? In short, it
>::: is about the multiple health benefits of consuming plant-
>::: based foods, and the largely unappreciated health dangers
>::: of consuming animal-based foods, including all types of
>::: meat, dairy, and eggs."
>::: [...]
>:::
>::: Campbell is at his best when writing about "Broken Hearts"
>::: on page 111. You will learn that during the Korean War, 77.3
>::: percent of healthy hearts autopsied from American casualties
>::: revealed advanced heart disease. These diseased hearts were
>::: taken from the bodies of so-called healthy males who had
>::: eaten the standard American diet. Campbell offers the hows
>::: and whys of heart disease...and the cure-all.
>::: [...]
>:: So the answer to great health is following an unnatural, low-fat
>:: plant-based diet? First off, humans were never vegetarian, despite
>:: what the vegetarian's will have you believe. Secondly, low-fat is a
>:: modern (1970s, 1980's, etc) manmade creation and is difficult to
>:: follow. Hmmmm, could it be that when you restrict fat your body is
>:: trying to tell you something? It is sad when one's diet becomes their
>:: religion. :o(
>
>Here are some of my impressions after reading the book. As I have said
>before the title of the book is misleading as the book is *not* mostly about
>the China study. It is a general book about what Campbell considers to be a
>healthy diet. I have admit that Campbell is very convincing when he speaks
>about the health benefits of plant-based diets, but at the same time there
>is also a certain bias through out the whole book and I don't feel that
>Campbell is totally honest in his approach. Even though Campbell writes
>about the prevention of cardiovascular diseases he fails to mention the
>Seven Countries Study, the Lyon Heart Study, Greece and Crete. Even the
>Mediterranean diet is not mentioned at all, which is strange as Campbell
>speaks very strongly in favor of the Ornish diet and its benefits in the
>cardiovascular diseases. Campbell also passes the omega-3 fatty acids and
>fish oils very briefly and with contempt. If the book were mainly about
>China, these defects might be understandable, but the book is not. I would
>say that it is a book worth of reading but with certain reservations.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: The China Study - book published
    ... :: diabetes, heart disease and obesity. ... :: Diet and Health Project) as the "Grand Prix of epidemiology" and the ... :: These results could not be ignored," said Dr. Campbell. ... about the China study. ...
    (sci.med.nutrition)
  • Re: The China Study
    ... :: I have heard Campbell speak and yes, ... believe in the Seven Countries Study there are countless other studies ... against the Atkins diet, but he refuses to partake to an intelligent ... discussion about the health benefits of a traditional Mediterranean type of ...
    (sci.med.nutrition)