Re: The sound of a laser.

From: tadchem (tadchemNOSPAM_at_comcast.net)
Date: 08/20/04


Date: Fri, 20 Aug 2004 01:42:07 -0400


"David Prokopetz" <sirbob@penguinking.com> wrote in message
news:2ol510Fbmdq4U1@uni-berlin.de...
> Hi.
>
> Physics newbie question here: what does a laser sound like?

It sounds like Zen to me...
:-P

> Some sources
> I've read claim that a sufficiently powerful laser would ionise the air
> along its path

True. If the electrons in the "air" atoms are able to absorb light energy
of the particular wavelength, the atoms/molecules can ionize. If enough of
them do it, then the gas in the path of the laser will expand thermally and
produce a pressure wave (a "pop") as the system of
light-atoms/molecules-ions-electrons approaches thermal equilibrium.

> and produce a "crackle" or "pop" noise, while others claim
> that regardless of power, a laser has to be of a particular colour to
ionise
> the air and thus produce a sound

Also true. Each type of atoms/molecule (nitrogen, oxygen, argon, carbon
dioxide, etc) absorbs different wavelength. A vacuum absorbs nothing at
all.

Unfiltered air can also contain dust particles of indeterminate composition
which may absorb or scatter the light as they drift into a continuous beam.
This *could* give rise to a crackling sound.

> - but fail to mention what that colour is.

Sort of depends on what the exact composition of your "air" is, doesn't it.
Unlike natural air. synthetic air contains no argon, water vapor, carbon
dioxide, methane, helium, or trace gases. The wavelengths absorbed by these
species are less likely to be absorbed in synthetic air.

> Is any of this information accurate?

In the sense of being qualitatively correct, yes.

"Accurate" is a term usually reserved in the empirical sciences for
measurements/predictions that are within predetermined limits of precision
established by analysis of the data and techniques used to perform
measurements.

> As a follow-up question, if a laser actually can make noise, is there an
> easy way to derive an approximate relationship between how powerful the
> laser is and how loud it is?

Yes. Empirically would be easiest and most reliable.

Make repeatable measurements under the actual operational parameters of
interest. Control the power/time curve of the laser, the composition and
temperature and pressure of the gas, the environmental noise, and the
distance/sensitivity of the audio transducers ("microphones") from the beam.

Tom Davidson
Richmond, VA



Relevant Pages

  • Re: The sound of a laser.
    ... A few mJ is enough for air breakdown from a low f/ number focused Q-switched ... there is the sound of the caps discharging. ... >> At high instantaneous laser powers the ossilating electric field in ... >> electric field. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: The sound of a laser.
    ... A few mJ is enough for air breakdown from a low f/ number focused Q-switched ... there is the sound of the caps discharging. ... >> At high instantaneous laser powers the ossilating electric field in ... >> electric field. ...
    (sci.optics)
  • Re: The sound of a laser.
    ... > I've read claim that a sufficiently powerful laser would ionise the air ... mechanism for a laser to ionize air. ... crackling sound. ...
    (sci.optics)
  • Re: The sound of a laser.
    ... > I've read claim that a sufficiently powerful laser would ionise the air ... mechanism for a laser to ionize air. ... crackling sound. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Why does fire have a shadow??
    ... shouldn't it absorb parts of the lamp's light? ... Lets take a case where air is hot but not incandescent. ... cannot see any shadow with a laser. ...
    (sci.physics)