Re: I have an idea for a stable light-source, but is there a market for it?



spinning writes:

For the sake of discussion, let me ask you: In your opinion,
do you think Coca Cola would have done better to disclose their
beverage formulation, and not keep it a trade secret?

The formula is not a secret. Ask any flavor chemist. "Secret" perfumes,
flavors, cosmetics, etc., are better valued by the consumer, so a cachet of
secrecy is a common marketing angle, even though you're just blending from
the same Aldrich catalog.

People who think their gadget/gizmo ideas are valuable as just misguided.
This is not uncommon. The "better mousetrap" myth. Your uncle had that
improved wrench, remember? When they get secretive about it, then they're
getting into schizoid territory.

Come back and talk when you have bragging rights. That means, you have a
genuine patent that actually generated tax-return income above the fees and
time invested. Until then, sorry, chances are about five nines that you're
a nut.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Windows 2000 Source Code File
    ... A trade secret is a trade ... >> secret only as long as it remains secret. ... > Is the source code not protected under US Copyright law? ... Chances are they will go copyright infringement ...
    (comp.os.linux.security)
  • Re: 60 Minutes last night...
    ... will disclose it and not keep it secret. ... I'm not arguing that some candidates can't and don't disclose ... Contributions over $200 must be disclosed by law. ...
    (rec.music.gdead)
  • Re: What am I doing wrong?
    ... in law?) ... > entitled to someone elses data? ... You are free to keep it secret or require an NDA from everyone ... when you disclose your data to people who have not agreed to keep ...
    (comp.os.linux.setup)
  • Re: 60 Minutes last night...
    ... If I were to donate $50 to Obama, ... will disclose it and not keep it secret. ... their small contributions if they choose to. ...
    (rec.music.gdead)
  • Re: OT Re: Cherokee Nation Posts Open Source Legisation
    ... >> they protect the trade secret within, but such code is not open source. ...
    (Linux-Kernel)

Quantcast