BIG PONG - Farewell George

From: Polyglot (denisNOSPAMfree_at_msn.com)
Date: 06/20/04 

Date: Mon, 21 Jun 2004 09:57:13 +1000

Enough is enough. I refuse to put up with this nonsense any more. As I and
certainly many others have pointed out, you refuse to utilise a scientific
epistemology either experimentally or theoretically. You reject scietific
method yet refuse to explain your own. From observation you can change
definitions of things as and when you feel like it. Even during the same
proof ! If you don't feel like it you don't even have to define something -
but still claim you can measure it to two decimal places. You are not bound
by rules of logic. You can simultaneously prove , not only that

1) x = y For all x and for all y BUT ALSO
2) x ¬= y For any x and for any y

I cannot see any use for such a system that can "prove god exists" or
equally "validly" simultaneously prove "god does not exist". I have already
used your method to "prove" god does not exist yet you refused to comment.

I showed some of your work to the eleven year old next door (I don't know
why , he has never done anything against me) and he was able to spot a
significant number of scientific flaws. To the best of my knowledge he does
not have a PhD unless PhD (bad Karaoke singing). I am not wasting any more
time explaining the flaws in your approach. Go ask an 11 year old - they can
spot the flaws too, and they probably haven't studied general relativity.

So goodbye George - but you will be forever remembered - by my killfile.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Doctor Who Apologist
    ... The fool says in his heart, "There is no God". ... John Byrne ... and does he refuse to listen to bands such as Pink Floyd, ... ...and refuse to watch films starring Jack Nicholson, ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: The Rich Man and Lazarus
    ... refuse to help others in their misfortune despite being easily ... God himself seems very much like this rich man! ... Christianity says one should is a particular problem for Christianity ...
    (uk.religion.christian)
  • Re: The logic of atheism
    ... least one god exists" but we'll let it stand here. ... greater than zero and it is the case that a non-positive number is not ... Deny ... To refuse to grant; to withhold; to refuse to gratify or yield to; as, ...
    (talk.atheism)
  • Re: The original Sin
    ... >>> I think I understand you OK on this, but why would God refuse paradise ... >> I'm not saying Allah refused anyone. ... But even if He did refuse someone ... > sinless person from paradise makes him out to be rather arbitrary. ...
    (uk.religion.islam)
  • Re: Relationship with God (Re: Russian chessboard killer convicted of 48 murders)
    ... [me, to David Albo after he suggested that God, so to speak, ... punishment which is for those who refuse God's invitation, ...
    (uk.religion.christian)