Re: Relativity IQ Test. Synching Clocks Absolutely.

From: Paul B. Andersen (paul.b.andersen_at_hia.no)
Date: 08/24/04


Date: Tue, 24 Aug 2004 13:15:37 +0200


"Henri Wilson" <h@..> skrev i melding news:ihmki0t6qhflprqmdd9eduphv2b4jkntdc@4ax.com...
> Check this experiment.
>
> The readings and rates of three clocks A, B and C are synched whilst the are
> together.
> B and C are then moved in opposite directions to positions on a long calibrated
> rod.
>
> -----------------------------B-------------A-------------C---------------------------------
>
> B and C now check that their rates are the same (they should be). They also
> compare readings by sending time signals to each other and comparing the signal
> arrival times with their own clocks.
> Any discrepancy between the arrival in either direction will reveal that either
> their readings have changed or light speed is different in opposite directions.
>
> Clock A is now moved to a position at the LH end of the rod.
>
> A->v
> -----------------------------B----------------------------C---------------------------------
>
> A is then set in motion towards B and C, at velocity v wrt the rod.
> As A passes B, B's reading is set to that of A.
> As A passes C, C's reading is set to that of A.
>
> If A's rate has NOT been affected by its movement, the three clocks should now
> be in absolute synch.
>
> If A's rate HAS been affected by its movement then B and C will not read
> absolutely the same. B and C can be brought together to check this.
> *******************************************
> Without changing any of the clock settings, the experiment is now repeated but
> with A moving from the RH end of the rod. While the clocks are all at rest,
> their rates are checked. They should all be the same.
> v<-A
> -----------------------------B----------------------------C---------------------------------
>
> As A passes B, B makes note of A's reading.
> As A passes C, C makes note of A's reading.
>
> If A's reading is still the same as B's and C's respectively, then it is proved
> that velocity does not affect clock rates and the three clocks are absolutely
> synched.
>
>
> If they do not agree, it is proved that A's rate is definitely affected by its
> movement . B and C must now confer.
>
> Since A moves at the same speed relative to the rod in opposite directions, its
> rate must have changed by the same amount in each case. That is because v
> appears as a quadratic in the term 'gamma'.
>
> It should therefore be a simple matter to use the differences in readings to
> correct B and C so that they ARE in absolute synch.
>
> So whatever the outcome of this experiment, it is possible to synch clocks
> absolutely.
>
> Therefore simultaneity is also absolute.
>
> 'NOW' here is 'NOW' everywhere.
>
> Einsteinian Relativity is plain BULL!!!!!

I would say your score is about 30.

Paul



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Relativity IQ Test. Synching Clocks Absolutely.
    ... So C's reading will lag B's by *) ... >between averaging the times as you have proposed and E-syncing, ... Clocks B and C have been absolutely synched in all frames. ... It is called absolute synching. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Relativity IQ Test. Synching Clocks Absolutely.
    ... >> The readings and rates of three clocks A, B and C are synched whilst the ... >> Clock A is now moved to a position at the LH end of the rod. ... >> passes B, B's reading is set to that of A. As A passes C, C's reading is ... >> readings to correct B and C so that they ARE in absolute synch. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Motion Through Space Is Meaningful
    ... >> proper length, i.o.w. ... clocks do not physically ... measure the speed of an object - without using a rod. ... Sitting absolutely still in the absolute frame ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Relativity IQ Test. Synching Clocks Absolutely.
    ... The readings and rates of three clocks A, B and C are synched whilst the are ... Clock A is now moved to a position at the LH end of the rod. ... B's reading is set to that of A. ... correct B and C so that they ARE in absolute synch. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Relativity IQ Test. Synching Clocks Absolutely.
    ... SR says they might not be in 'reading synch'. ... The clocks are not E-synched anywhere. ... to also be in absolute synch even though they are now apart. ... >or some other E-syncing proxy to see if their time still agrees. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)

Loading