Re: johnreed take 9

From: Lady Chatterly (randamajor_at_catcher.in.the.rye)
Date: 02/10/05


Date: Thu, 10 Feb 2005 3:33:32 GMT

In article <1107995441.919402.166770@c13g2000cwb.googlegroups.com>
randamajor@yahoo.com wrote:
>
>The thought experiments involving two observers measuring the speed of
>light from different locations were used to show the dilation of time
>and space when holding lightspeed constant for both observers. The
>experiments were not only impossible to perform but contained an
>elemental error. Both observers were measuring the trail of a
>lightpulse as it traveled through space. This is not a physical
>possibility as we do not see light. We see illuminated objects. The
>entire offering was to show that the Lorentz equation measured the
>degree of dilation and/or contraction.
>
>Such a bizarre thought experiment is not possible, nor is it even
>required to account for the observers constant measure of lightspeed.
>To the extent we measure lightspeed at all, and certainly within the
>confines of the thought experiments, one would use detectors to measure
>the speed of light. One persons detector is the same as anothers in
>that both will detect either EMR frequency or EMR wavelength or both.
>Since we have a continuous spectrum for light, the measure of which
>will always be a function of frequency or wavelength, a detector
>designed to measure a certain frequency or multiple frequencies, will
>always measure lightspeed as a function of frequency or wavelength,
>even though the detectors motion may change the particular frequency
>measured.

Wow.

>The entire notion of time dilation in the sense proposed by Einstein is
>conceptually misleading. For example, the extended life of the muon is
>due to energy conservation and has no reference to a literal space-time
>dimension.

If muslims are against the ps3.

>The wavelike nature of light propagation caused physicists to invoke
>the luminiferous ether to account for its propagation, since waves
>require a medium to travel through. Beyond the local or perceived
>requirement for a medium, the propagation of energy in a wavelike
>manner is efficient. So, rather than require a medium for light
>propagation perhaps all we need do is seek a means that is efficient,
>absent a medium. Indeed, EMR propagation is most efficient in a vacuum.

Nothing.

>The key element for light propagation is a source of emission. The
>actual wave propagation of light energy has heretofore been viewed in
>somewhat of a Newtonian manner. Once emitted, light is thought to
>continue its motion just as though it possessed momentum.

Darkness reigns at the foot of the lighthouse.

>I say that light is pushed from its source and once the source
>terminates emission the EMR ceases its linear travel. Moreover the
>source of light must exist for the human eye to register its image.

To err is human; to mimic, requires a bot.

--
Lady Chatterly
"Someone needs to learn Our Good Lady about the St. Foamy moratorium!"
-- Art Deco


Relevant Pages

  • johnreed take 9
    ... The thought experiments involving two observers measuring the speed of ... and space when holding lightspeed constant for both observers. ... degree of dilation and/or contraction. ... The wavelike nature of light propagation caused physicists to invoke ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Another Question They Cannot Answer
    ... A 500 yo willusion of that star, ... measuring the length as it is NOW but as it was a little while ago? ... Observers simply make mistakes in their measurements of it. ... Length IS an intrinsic property of the rod. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Another Question They Cannot Answer
    ... A 500 yo willusion of that star, ... measuring the length as it is NOW but as it was a little while ago? ... Observers simply make mistakes in their measurements of it. ... Length IS an intrinsic property of the rod. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Comments on my FAQ page (was: What become...)
    ... observers, because real observers live in the real world which cannot be ... different transformations relating different observers' coordinates. ... Please show how SR predicts this relativistic mass. ... moving medium differs from the speed in the medium at rest, ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Eric Gisse, your comment was ridiculous
    ... In sci.math, eleaticus ... The intent is to represent the viewpoint of two observers. ... The second uses, when measuring spacetime events. ... One can contemplate the existence of an identity time transform ...
    (sci.physics)