Question from a non-physics person



A common question is posed when trying to find solutions to the problem
of near light speed travel (assuming we had knowledge to produce such
speeds): "How does your ship avoid getting pulverized by tiny grains in
space that would impact your ship with enormous energy?"

>>From what I understand as your ship approaches the speed of light, its
mass would also increase to near infinite. These tiny objects would
not have enormous amounts of energy; the ship would, so the ship would
be the one doing the pulverizing.

There are everyday examples of this: Tornados can accelerate common hay
or dried grass to speeds of 300 mph, increasing their mass, and drive
them right through trees and telephone poles. If you accelerated a
tree or telephone pole to 300 mph, and shot it through a field of
hay, it would mow down the hay, not split into a thousand pieces.

So why do I continuously see this question posed as a problem of near
light speed travel? I understand larger objects that have mass more
equal to the near-light speed ship (comet, planet, etc.) would be a
danger, but not tiny particles. What am I not taking into
consideration? Thanks

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Small sailing ship help
    ... speed, but it is a decreasing function at lower speeds, which means a ... longer hull still gains an advantage. ... force is proportional to wind speed**2. ... Surely that's wind speed relative to the ship. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.composition)
  • Re: Colony ship to Alpha Centauri - The Motion Picture Concept by A. Ahad
    ... interstellar travel and the ship never attains speeds much greater than ... The mining is going to be very infrequently ... of MMC appointed judges, who exercise judicial duties in conformance to ...
    (sci.electronics.equipment)
  • Re: Question from a non-physics person
    ... of near light speed travel: "How does your ship avoid getting pulverized by tiny grains in space that would impact your ship with enormous energy?" ... only move at such speeds in regions where the chance of hitting such "grains" is negligible. ... tree or telephone pole to 300 mph, and shot it through a field of hay, it would mow down the hay, not split into a thousand pieces. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Refueling at sea
    ... why is it the ship "taking on fuel" as opposed to the smaller or handier ship? ... Usually the receiving vessel approaches the tanker/oiler but not ... the holder of the ship's conn orders the helm corrections by ... typical UNREP/RAS speeds of 8-14 kts), ...
    (sci.military.naval)
  • Re: Question from a non-physics person
    ... > of near light speed travel (assuming we had knowledge to produce such ... > space that would impact your ship with enormous energy?" ... << A common analogy is the sonic boom of a supersonic aircraft or bullet. ... > or dried grass to speeds of 300 mph, increasing their mass, and drive ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)