Re: Logical inconsistency in Lorentz's theory


"Bilge" <dubious@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:slrndj2or7.60p.dubious@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Koobee Wublee:
>
> >
> >I find your 2nd point faulty. Lorentz Transforms do not prove nor
> >disprove
> >the existence of the Aether.
>
> They do disprove the existence of any ether that could reasonably be
> called a medium is the sense for which the ether was postulated.

Prove it, then.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: my gravity theory - Web Link
    ... Our version of ether claims it to be the only substance ... in existence, and also claims that it is not composed of smaller particles'. ... The evidence I have seen says otherwise. ... aether wind would break the POR) and coulombs law leads to Maxwell's ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Logical inconsistency in Lorentzs theory
    ... >> Anyone can come up with a set of properties or lack of it [no Aether ... > outlined) then the ether is falsified. ... > meaning of a "frame dependent ether". ... Lorentz Transforms do not prove nor disprove ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: AETHER / OR
    ... Now do the same for aether. ... forgetting the ether interpretation of a given continous ether theory and ... The existence of an ether ... property this would be a quite nontrivial fact about our universe. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Logical inconsistency in Lorentzs theory
    ... Unless you can demonstrate how the observable result based on Lorentz Transforms would behave differently from one theory to another, you don't have anything to show for. ... I did in fact *demonstrate* how the observed result based upon the Lorentz Transform would behave differently than prescribed by physical shortening of rods and physical ticking rate offsets due to motion and interaction with a fixed ether. ... With no interaction with the ether there is a symmetry wrt every frame, thus an interaction would naturally require an asymmetry, which is not predicted by the lorentz transform, nor one that is observed in nature. ... Lorentz Transforms do not prove nor disprove the existence of the Aether. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: my gravity theory - Web Link
    ... Michelson-Morley was attempting to test the existence of from the ... >> support the existence of my ether model. ... I'm citing the observation of gravity and magnetism itself are ... reality so in a sense, I'm trying to 'fit' the evidence, other than the ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
Quantcast