Androcles' and Henri's Theory of Diffraction Grating Behavior
- From: "Jerry" <Cephalobus_alienus@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: 5 Oct 2005 08:01:11 -0700
Androcles wrote:
> "Jerry" <Cephalobus_alienus@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
> news:1128495977.675678.20680@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> | Androcles wrote:
> |
> | > Why are you trying to divert attention from the issue?
> | > You stated "wavelengths _are_ Doppler shifted in the
> } > real world".
> | > I've asked you to prove it.
> |
> | 1) Spectra from near versus distant galaxies are
> | differentially shifted by diffraction gratings.
>
> A proof of frequency shift when combined with the
> vector addition of velocities, an axiom.
> wavecrest count per second = \nu = (c+v)/ \lambda
> See Doppler.
>
>
> | 2) Traditional theory on diffraction gratings successfully
> | explains the diffraction angle as a function of wavelength,
> | incident angle, and grating spacing.
>
> Non sequitur, you have not proven a wavelength shift.
>
> | 3) Nobody, including Androcles and Henri, has ever offered
> | an alternative theory of diffraction grating behavior
> | explaining the diffraction angle as a function of
> | frequency, velocity of light, incident angle, and grating
> | spacing as would be required by the ballistic theory.
>
> Non sequitur, you didn't ask me, and wouldn't listen anyway.
>
>
> | 4) Until such theory is offered, it must be concluded that
> | traditional diffraction grating theory is correct.
>
> Non sequitur, you have not proven a wavelength shift.
>
> | 5) Therefore, all extant theory points to wavelengths
> | being Doppler shifted in the real world.
>
> Non sequitur, you have not proven a wavelength shift.
To Androcles and Henri:
Please present a mathematically consistent model of
diffraction grating behavior, explaining diffraction
angle as a function of frequency, velocity of light,
incident angle, and grating spacing, and which is
consistent with the ballistic theory.
Jerry
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Androcles' and Henri's Theory of Diffraction Grating Behavior
- From: Androcles
- Re: Androcles' and Henri's Theory of Diffraction Grating Behavior
- From: Dirk Van de moortel
- Re: Androcles' and Henri's Theory of Diffraction Grating Behavior
- Prev by Date: Re: The true crackpots
- Next by Date: Re: Sal the crackpot
- Previous by thread: "Examining Mathematical Approaches"
- Next by thread: Re: Androcles' and Henri's Theory of Diffraction Grating Behavior
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
