Re: Nikola Tesla about Relativity


"JanPB" <filmart@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1136584996.868652.263760@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> Koobee Wublee wrote:
>>
>> In 1914, Einstein and Grossmann published the "Entwurf" theory of gravity
>> where the field equations were very close to the modern day form. It is
>> more like Grossmann did all the work while Eintein did all the PR stuff.
>> Hilbert being corresponding with Einstein must have known about
>> "Entwurf".
>> He also knew the field equations must encompass the Poisson equation.
>> Therefore, he must have tried all sorts of Lagrangian until one fits his
>> liking. He came up with the Lagrangian by "fudging" and not by the old
>> fashion way that is to derive it from something already well established.
>
> This doesn't seem right. It's been few years since I looked into the
> Birkhauser "Einstein and the History of General Relativity" series but
> it's all there based on research from the recently opened Einstein
> Archive (late '80s). J. Stachel, J. Norton, and many others go into
> full technical and historical detail supported by notebooks, letters,
> galley proofs of the original papers with authors' corrections (not
> only Einstein's, of course), etc. etc., tracing the development of
> every important idea of GR and who did what. It's a fascinating and
> complicated business, none of which looked to me like "fudging" some
> Lagrangian or "Grossmann did all the work while Einstein did all the PR
> stuff".
>
> It's all there, it's no secret, if you have the time and the
> inclination you can study it.
>
> --
> Jan Bielawski

Since you don't understand this stuff, why don't you refrain from
posting on this thread? What's your point?
Hexenmeister.


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Nikola Tesla about Relativity
    ... >>Hilbert being corresponding with Einstein must have known about ... >>He also knew the field equations must encompass the Poisson equation. ... he must have tried all sorts of Lagrangian until one fits his ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Nikola Tesla about Relativity
    ... > more like Grossmann did all the work while Eintein did all the PR stuff. ... > Hilbert being corresponding with Einstein must have known about "Entwurf". ... > He also knew the field equations must encompass the Poisson equation. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Nikola Tesla about Relativity
    ... > Koobee Wublee wrote: ... >> There is no doubt that Einstein is a plagirist. ... >> where the field equations were very close to the modern day form. ... he must have tried all sorts of Lagrangian until one fits his ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Curvature vs matter by KST
    ... here is the derivation of the field equations. ... the Lagrangian which does not even satisfy as a Lagrangian according ... There is no need to disparage Einstein. ... GR was created through mathematics that makes no justification for it ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Nikola Tesla about Relativity
    ... > There is no doubt that Einstein is a plagirist. ... Hilbert's Lagrangian was ... > Hilbert's last desperate attempt to arrive at the field equations before ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
Quantcast