Re: Religion vs SR?

"Bilge" <dubious@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:slrne9ekho.fv3.dubious@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Julian Becker:
>
>so you dont see my point?!

No, but if you post a picture of yourself without a hat on, I think
you can make it obvious.

>Alas!
>Just answer my question from above: That coordinate system he defined
>is about coordinates in _what sort of space_?

Gee, the coordinate system that pythaoreas (and later newton) assumed
is in what sort of space? Do you realize that you have to assume
a euclidean space if you expect d^2 = x^2 + y^2 to correspond to
the length of a line?

>Please tell me about this space.

Well, let's see... It's just like the one pythagoreas and newton
assumed except that instead of having all + signs in the pythagorean
theorem, there is a single minus sign. Is there some reason you think
the definition of length is an edict from god to be euclidean rather
than chosen to be the one which best conforms to what we observe from
natural phenomena?

nonsense, Bilge.

You have admitted yourself that t' and x' are useless except for calculating
what the moving system sees,
completely missing the obvious, which is that the moving system coordinate
never does correspond to that x' and t'.

And those values are the space and time values in concern.

There is absolutely no circumstance in the universe, past, present, or
future in which SR's t' and x' have been, are, or will be of any utility
except pablum for SR-cult idiots.



--
(c) eleaticus
ee-lee-AT-i-cus
http://eleaticus.blog-city.com







.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Religion vs SR?
    ... Just answer my question from above: That coordinate system he defined ... is about coordinates in _what sort of space_? ... the coordinate system that pythaoreas (and later newton) assumed ... It's just like the one pythagoreas and newton ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: SRs velocity addition -- ANY Experimental Evidence?
    ... >> It was obviously meant that all motion was converted. ... > What is wrong with the tree having non-zero KE in some coordinate system? ... > So, there you are, directly attacking the work of Galileo and Newton. ... Velocity of objects is a vector...use vector addition! ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: SRs velocity addition -- ANY Experimental Evidence?
    ... >> It was obviously meant that all motion was converted. ... > What is wrong with the tree having non-zero KE in some coordinate system? ... > So, there you are, directly attacking the work of Galileo and Newton. ... Velocity of objects is a vector...use vector addition! ...
    (sci.physics)