Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- From: "LEJ Brouwer" <intuitionist1@xxxxxxxxx>
- Date: 14 Jul 2006 17:33:17 -0700
JanPB wrote:
LEJ Brouwer wrote:
No, no, no, no, please let go of those dreams at once. A far simpler
explanation: your papers are not good enough. There is no need to
search for grand explanations and Hollywoodesque "establishment"
conspiracies when good old plain incompetence suffices. If you don't
know how coordinate labels relate to tensor equations then there is
really nothing to add, is there?
Hmm, I think you are possibly confusing me with the entire population
of America. I do not claim that there is some kind of conspiracy going
on. It is just a sad state of affairs and this is just how the current
system works. As someone said, if Einstein were around today, he would
probably have a Yahoo or Hotmail email account and his submissions
would not be accepted by the arxiv. Its a shame, but that's just how
things are. Maybe my papers are not 'good enough' for whatever reason
(I have not actually submitted most of my papers for publication) but I
will still stand by my results, because I am confident that the
mathematics is sound. Nothing you have said has convinced me otherwise.
Remember that 101 years ago a certain no-name government bureaucrat in
Switzerland was able to publish what you would call an
anti-establishment paper. So much for not being able to publish because
of discussing unpopular ideas.
--
Jan Bielawski
So you seriously believe that things work in the same way now as they
did 101 years ago? Any you accuse me of wishful thinking!
.
- References:
- Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- From: LEJ Brouwer
- Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- From: dda1
- Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- From: LEJ Brouwer
- Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- From: dda1
- Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- From: LEJ Brouwer
- Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- From: JanPB
- Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- Prev by Date: derivation of kinetic energy
- Next by Date: Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- Previous by thread: Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- Next by thread: Re: Misinterpretation of the radial parameter in the Schwarzschild solution?
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|