Re: Special Relativity is Dead! (second proof)


Brian Kennelly schreef:

The acceleration does not lead to burst of clock pulses. It
leads to change in the Doppler factor. The rate at which the
pulses are received increases smoothly during the acceleration,
and then remains steady when the acceleration ends.

That means that there will be a conflict between the clocks upon
arrival home of the traveling clock. The traveling clock is ahead of
the stationary clock (based on received timing pulses) and the
stationary clock is ahead of the traveling clock (based on application
of S.R., which would at least be valid for the stationary clock,
according to proponents of S.R.).


The rest of the argument is based on this error, and your
conclusion does not follow.

You belong to the few who address the details of my experiment, Brian.
However, your argument is wrong. S.R. needs a burst of clock pulses
during acceleration to ensure consistency of clocks upon home arrival
of the traveling clock.

Regards, Jan.

.

Relevant Pages

  • Zwillingsparadoxon ohne Beschleunigung von Uhren.
    ... asymmetry (not the effect). ... Acceleration breaks the symmetry of who ages faster. ... breaking the symmetry of clock observation. ... which reference frame takes what path through spacetime - even if it ...
    (de.sci.physik)
  • Re: Special Relativity is Dead! (second proof)
    ... of inertial frame. ... As soon as the traveling clock arrives back at ... time dilation is not a function of acceleration ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Lesch: Zwillingsparadoxon NUR wegen Beschleunigung
    ... Acceleration is irrelevant to the Twin Paradox except to break the ... arbitrary time not associated with the experiment itself for breaking ... the symmetry of clock observation. ... Any accelerated reference frame has a different mixture ...
    (de.sci.physik)
  • Special Relativity is Dead! (second proof)
    ... There IS NO theory in which the universe appears the same, ... There is a twin-experiment possible with only one acceleration, ... As soon as the traveling clock arrives back at ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Special Relativity is Dead! (second proof)
    ... There IS NO theory in which the universe appears the same, ... There is a twin-experiment possible with only one acceleration, ... As soon as the traveling clock arrives back at ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)