Re: symmetric twins paradox

Sue... wrote:
dlzc wrote:
Dear Sue:

Sue... wrote:
N:dlzc D:aol T:com (dlzc) wrote:
Dear lkoluk2003:

<lkoluk2003@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1164106119.311251.148050@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
If you did the math, observer A sees observer B's clock
go very slowly on A's outbound, continue slowly for some
time with A inbound (since B's start-of-return doesn't reach
A until later) then sees B's clock rate increase until it
meets A at Earth, with net 0 difference at Earth.

So three observers in a symmetric situation yields two
results, because only two unique paths are described.

It is the words that trick your common sense, not the facts.
Use the math.
In response to your complaints about the elastic properties
of today's garden hose material and the possibility of
"bead bunching", we are proud to announce the all new and
improved
Three clocks, two different elapsed times. Argument? Beads, hoses?
I'm not looking to buy Manhattan...

:o)

Uhmm Kimosabe, Manhattan cost you heapum wampum.

I'll let the web publishing of Unnikrishnan, Fitzpatrick and MIT
serve as my argument for *this* thread because the OP doesn't
mention resolution of the postulates and that is where an SR
discussion needs to go to be productive for the OP.

We can discuss equal length path techniques in a thread
where electromagnetism is not the focus. I was just injecting
some humor, not intending to do anything to interfere with
the remote possibility that the discussion might wander off
into the physics arena. ;-)


Regards,

Sue...

There is no risk that you ever will wander into the physics arena.
You are babbling a lot about hoses and marbles, but you are
utterly unable to explain how you would use them to prove
your claims.

You flee like hell every time someone asks you to do so.
Like you did now.

Paul
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: symmetric twins paradox
    ... observer A sees observer B's clock ... A until later) then sees B's clock rate increase until it ... Use the math. ... string count as well as marbles in a hose. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: symmetric twins paradox
    ... observer A sees observer B's clock ... A until later) then sees B's clock rate increase until it ... Use the math. ... string count as well as marbles in a hose. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Explaining Time Dilation
    ... > examining Doppler time we find it has none of these deficiencies. ... When Einstein perceived the difference of the clock readings ... > velocity vectors - and vectors are directional. ... > of time each twin is an observer is equal to the time he is observed. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: The Single Experiment that Destroys Einstein.
    ... Both the OO and the ground observer count the number of ticks the ... GC (ground clock) emits PER ORBIT OF THE OO. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Time dilation
    ... No ticks can be lost or gained ... | There are two methods of calculating how many ticks the earth observer ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
Quantcast