Re: Question about analysis of Schwarzschild solution on Fo. of Phys. 1988, 18, 6


Eric Gisse ha escrito:

Juan R. wrote:
It is well-known the role that classical Schwarzschild solution play in
the classical tests of GR as Mercury perihelion anomaly.

Recently i was thought that solution is a sheer imposibility because
the Schw solution requires at the same time

T_1{}^1 = T_0{}^0

AND

T_0{}^0 as the only non-zero component of T_a{}^b

The Schwarzschild solution is the *vacuum* solution where T_ab = 0. All
the components of T should be zero _by assumption_.

At Mercuri position T_ab /= 0 (textbooks typical solution is a 1-body
one) and at Sun T_ab /= 0 also. Since i have no current acess to that
paper i do not know they studied. I suspect that the work may be
related to analitic continuation to 'internal' (surface) region but i
do not know.


He cites Narlikar and Padmanabhan. Found. of Physics 1988, 18, 6.

Someone with a copy of that paper? Some public rebuttal published or
so?

Without a copy of the work i cannot understand from where they claim
two different values for the T-00.

.