Re: On the light-like interval



<jt64@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1175937362.619148.20970@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
On 7 Apr, 02:51, "Bill Hobba" <rubb...@xxxxxxxx> wrote:
"Phil" <cms...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
On Apr 6, 5:58 pm, "Jeckyl" <n...@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
"Phil" <cms...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message

news:1175903706.524698.28130@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Recently I came to the realization that the light-light interval is
an
interval whose end points describe the same point in space-time. So
it would seem that a light pulse is centered on a unique point in
space time. What troubles me is that, for every or any inertial
frame, there is an infinite number of "events" (coordinates) which
drive a stake into this same space time location. This lack of
uniqueness of a single event for every space-time location troubles
me. What am I missing?

Its just the one location as 'seen' from different points of view

The number of points of view makes no difference to the uniqueness of
the
location.

I don't think you understood what I meant. Say I have set up my own
inertial lab. I measure the movement of light in my frame. So there
is a series of events, between each is an space-time interval of zero,
which means that ALL of my measurements have staked the same location
in space-time. So I can drive an infinite number of stakes into the
same space-time location. In this sense, its not a unique location
for a specific event.

All you are alluding to is something trivially obvious - points of zero
distance using the Minkowsi metric do not have zero distance using the
Euclidian metric - such follows immediately from their definitions. As to
the physical implications - I suspect all you will arrive at is
meaningless
semantics.

So you try to tell that space events like a planet blocking the way of
a ship is meaningless, from point of causuality.

There was no mention of ships and planets in the post .. what are you
talking, and how is it related to what was being discussed?


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: On the light-like interval
    ... interval whose end points describe the same point in space-time. ... it would seem that a light pulse is centered on a unique point in ... drive a stake into this same space time location. ... an extension within Minkowski spacetime is just a ridiculous fantasy, ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: On the light-like interval
    ... interval whose end points describe the same point in space-time. ... drive a stake into this same space time location. ... All you are alluding to is something trivially obvious - points of zero ... no dimensional extension whatsoever in the space-time object, ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: On the light-like interval
    ... interval whose end points describe the same point in space-time. ... it would seem that a light pulse is centered on a unique point in ... All you are alluding to is something trivially obvious - points of zero ... Euclidean metrics are used in different contexts - treating then within the ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: On the light-like interval
    ... I think all of us can agree that a valid space-time object ... So we have two stakes related by LT's in the underlying space time. ... measurements of spatio-temporal paths that are thought to be ... zero length. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Space-time Analogies
    ... I decided to visit the Skirball cultural center?s Einstein exhibition in an ... the demonstration began by placing a billiard ball in the center to ... space-time caused by the mass of the billiard ball deflected the trajectory ... true nature of space time. ...
    (sci.astro)