Re: This is confusing - can someone explain?



Dear hjsb85:

<hjsb85@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:1177546395.153457.128530@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
I read (and learned in school) about time dilation and
the twins paradox - that is if you have one twin stay
on Earth and the other fly in a spaceship at relativistic
speeds, the one on Earth will be older when the
spacebound twin returns. Did I get that right?

You remembered it correctly.

Now, can it be said that the Earth and the Universe
itself is moving at relativistic speeds in relation to
the ship?

Yes. The very heart of relativity. You cannot tell by local
measurements which twin is "really" moving inertially.

If so, which twin will get older?

The one that accelerates. The "stay at home" twin does not
accelerate.

David A. Smith


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: This is confusing - can someone explain?
    ... paradox - that is if you have one twin stay on Earth and the other fly ... in a spaceship at relativistic speeds, the one on Earth will be older ... when the spacebound twin returns. ... So now let's bundle up Betty into the spacecraft and shoot her off into ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: This is confusing - can someone explain?
    ... paradox - that is if you have one twin stay on Earth and the other fly ... in a spaceship at relativistic speeds, the one on Earth will be older ... when the spacebound twin returns. ... can it be said that the Earth and the Universe itself is moving ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: This is confusing - can someone explain?
    ... paradox - that is if you have one twin stay on Earth and the other fly ... in a spaceship at relativistic speeds, the one on Earth will be older ... when the spacebound twin returns. ... with a constant RPM. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: twin patadox question
    ... Speak for yourself, Tom. ... comparison between the speeds of A and B. It does not mean speed of A ... > than the Earth. ... (and so the spaceship twin will definitely return ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: This is confusing - can someone explain?
    ... paradox - that is if you have one twin stay on Earth and the other fly ... in a spaceship at relativistic speeds, the one on Earth will be older ... when the spacebound twin returns. ... can it be said that the Earth and the Universe itself is moving ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)