Re: GR support for a preferred frame 2



Tom Roberts wrote:
Yes, GR does indeed have many manifolds in which there is a "preferred frame" that is "preferred" due to some symmetry of the manifold. You merely give one example.

Another example (as you know but the OP might not) is all versions of the FLRW geometry that's used to model our universe, even when space is flat or hyperbolic rather than (hyper)spherical. The "preferred frame" is observable as the state of motion with respect to which the CMBR is isotropic. Historically it was known as rest with respect to the fixed stars. It's also called the Hubble flow.

-- Ben
.



Relevant Pages

  • Message from Cahill that Relativity is wrong
    ... vacuum symmetry are two very well battle-tested ideas in physics today. ... specifically "Galilean relativity" as distinct from Lorentz-Einsteinian ... we have relativistic effects as well as absolute motion. ... "preferred frame of reference" means for all groups and all actions. ...
    (sci.math)
  • Message from Cahill that Relativity is wrong
    ... vacuum symmetry are two very well battle-tested ideas in physics today. ... specifically "Galilean relativity" as distinct from Lorentz-Einsteinian ... we have relativistic effects as well as absolute motion. ... "preferred frame of reference" means for all groups and all actions. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Message from Cahill that Relativity is wrong
    ... vacuum symmetry are two very well battle-tested ideas in physics today. ... specifically "Galilean relativity" as distinct from Lorentz-Einsteinian ... we have relativistic effects as well as absolute motion. ... "preferred frame of reference" means for all groups and all actions. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Time, Parameter, Operator
    ... of each individual physical system is the same (the fact we write the ... schroedinger equation in a non inertial frame. ... the operator associated to the time parameter commutes ... But the symmetry groups have nothing to do with the structure of the ...
    (sci.physics.research)
  • Theory of Everything
    ... The only issue I am concerned with here is whether Lorentz invariance is ... I am not arguing against spontaneously broken symmetry. ... AKA vacuum coherence of ZPF). ... there is a preferred frame which is to Oas the ferromagnetic order ...
    (sci.physics.particle)