Re: A challenge to Tom Roberts re LET,SR and an alternative.



On Nov 26, 3:06 am, John Kennaugh < wrote:

The reason I am aiming this post at Tom is that I know that he is one of
the few people on this NG who has actually studied Lorentz Ether Theory
from the mathematical PoV. [...]

Both LET and SR share the same mathematics --- the Lorentz transform.
They are, in each, merely different interpretations to the same
mathematics. It is ABSOLUTELY IMPOSSIBLE to prove which
interpretation is wrong. Since the Lorentz transform manifests the
nonsense of the twin's paradox as well as relative simultaneity, both
conjectures of LET and SR are manure of the same pile in height and
odor.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Proposal for an experiment to differentiate SRT from LET
    ... This is so because both theories use the same mathematics ... and LET are merely interpretations to interpret the mathematics of the ... Lorentz transform. ... theory but different interpretations to the faulty Lorentz transform. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Proposal for an experiment to differentiate SRT from LET
    ... This is so because both theories use the same mathematics ... and LET are merely interpretations to interpret the mathematics of the ... Lorentz transform. ... theory but different interpretations to the faulty Lorentz transform. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Proposal for an experiment to differentiate SRT from LET
    ... This is so because both theories use the same mathematics -- the ... and LET are merely interpretations to interpret the mathematics of the ... Lorentz transform. ... theory but different interpretations to the faulty Lorentz transform. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Proposal for an experiment to differentiate SRT from LET
    ... This is so because both theories use the same mathematics ... the Lorentz transform. ... Imagine you have a train with a laser mounted at right angles at X. ... We do not need to perform this experiment - It would hit T' not T just ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: A New Solution to the Twins Paradox, and Others
    ... You do not understand the Lorentz ... to the mathematics of the Lorentz transform. ... amount and duration of acceleration. ... Yes, only when you are not sucked into the faith of SR, you can think ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)

Loading