Re: time dilation



rbwinn wrote:

This brings us to another question about falling objects which
arises from the idea of dropping an object in a moving train car, which
writers of textbooks about relativity often use to show how the Lorentz
equations work. If a weight is dropped from the top of a train car to
the floor, [...].

You've really got three identical experiments there, the first one on
the train, a second that released where and when the train weight was
released, and a third that impacted where and when the train weight
impacted.
Stationary observers measure the second experiment as having started
before the third. The relitivistic observer measures the third one
starting before the second. There's no agreement on how the stationary
observers should measure the time taken for the train experiment relative
to their own, because they naturally disagree on the syncronicity of
events at a distance.

A nuetral observer could move so as to syncronise all three drops;
doing so would also syncronise all three impacts.

--
tussock

I'm like a box of chocolates; you never know what you're gunna get.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: = c + v (train)
    ... > in the path of the train... ... > Relativity. ... the observers have no SAY in the matter. ... > to open your mind to, all along, Jim. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Syncronized atomic clocks
    ... > The observers are not mistaken; they see the train shrink. ... > The effect is vaguely reminiscent of the image apparently in a mirror. ... "markers" on it, by which to compare motions (of photons, or anything ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Is time dilation real?
    ... > What if the train had a paint gun at each end and, ... We assume the balls fire straight forward. ... all observers are trapped at the ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: = c + v (train)
    ... >> In sci.physics, Jim Greenfield ... >> observers in the tunnel, just the train. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Is time dilation real?
    ... >> The Ghost In The Machine wrote: ... >>> electromagnetics to keep the train on the tracks). ... crapola about observers seeing this and that, ... > The distance from -4 to +4 depends on the units. ...
    (sci.physics)