The sound of gravity as dreamed by Johannes Kepler



I'm collecting evidences for speed of gravity and speed
of light near massive bodies. I can guess both speeds,
c_g and c are naturally linked in a beautiful form. But firstly,
I must define what speed of gravity, c_g, is. Suppose there
is a central massive body, with mass M, and a test body in
circular orbit at radius |r|. What will happen to that test body
if the central body magically and instantaneously vanishes?
Obviously, that test body will follow a tangent straight path with
a constant speed equals to its tanget speed v = sqrt(GM/|r|).
The question is, when will that event happen?. We know where
it will happen, it will happen at a distance |r| from the position of
the center of the massive body. Suppose now, the central body
vanishes instantaneously when the test body vector position, r,
has an angle phi_0 in a given inertial frame of reference (say wrt
fixed stars). Then, if the test body starts to move in a straight
path
when its vector position angle has that angle phi_0, at first glance,
we'd claim the speed of gravity from M to the test body would have
been infinite. But, if its angle is phi > phi_0, then the speed of
gravity
would have been finite. How can we quantify that speed of gravity
c_g?. In order to answer that question, we need to assume there is
a finite c_g. Suppose that value c_g and the radius |r| are such
that the test body starts to moves in a straight line at angular
position phi_0, but after it had performed a complete circular
revolution. As the angular speed of the test body is w = sqrt(GM/|r|
^3),
its period is T = 2pi/w, so the speed of gravity would be

c_g = |r|/T,
c_g = sqrt(GM / |r|) / (2 pi),

In general, we would always deduce the angular position
phi_0, for any

c_g = sqrt(GM / |r|) / (2 n pi),
with integer n = 0,1,2,3, ...

We clearly see an infinite speed of gravity, c_g = oo, is
deduced for n = 0. We can even replace the integer n,
by any positive real k

c_g = sqrt(GM / |r|) / (2 k pi).

Some questions arise naturally, is k a universal constant?
Can we claim conclusively that k=0? For constant fixed |r|
and k, we see c_g increases as M increases. For constant
fixed M and k, we see c_g decreases as |r| increases.

A wonderful conclusion would be the speed of gravity c_g is
actually the speed of sound! The denser the medium, the higher
c_g. Now, we see that the speed of light, c, behaves in an
opposite manner as that c_g. The denser the medium, the
lower the speed of light c. So, both speeds must be tightly
related.


.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: The speed of gravity revisited
    ... It concerns only the propagation speed of changes in the gravitational potential field, about which there is no dispute -- it is speed c. ... In particular, physics is concerned about the direction of the arrow of causality, whereas math is not. ... You need to study the two different physical interpretations of GR, then come to understand why one of them is now off the table, and why the other makes the physics of gravity easier to understand for everyone. ... is, in a static situation it simply is not possible to distinguish among models in which "gravitational force" propagates with different speeds, because for any propagation speed whatsoever one obtains the same "gravitational force" and its direction. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Uh Oh, Discrepancy Alert
    ... gravitational field has zillions of such 'locally inertial reference ... We do know it could be bent by the gravity of a star. ... it would indeed be accelerated to higher speeds as it ... speed of light is the same for all observers in inertial frames. ...
    (alt.machines.cnc)
  • Re: Going through time travel (distributed, not relativistic, 5 dimensions?)
    ... at much slower speeds than what the theory of relativity would predict ... I see dark matter as a speed deterrent force of gravity, ... Dynamic scale distribution. ...
    (sci.astro)
  • Re: The speed of gravity revisited
    ... Special relativity has now been falsified in favor of Lorentzian relativity. ... ** six experiments showing that the propagation speed of gravitational force is>> c, which contradicts SR, but is in accord with LR having no speed limit. ... If your only concern is that the Lorentz transformations do not work for speeds above c, the references explain why this is not a problem for LR. ... I am always careful to state that "the speed of gravity" measured by the six available experiments always means the 3-space propagation speed of gravitational force, and has nothing to do with changes in gravitational potential. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Tom Van Flandern and Newtonian Gravity
    ... replacement physics interpretations for the math of GR and QED. ... to the notion that superluminal speeds contradicted causality. ... propagation of gravity in forward time, ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)

Quantcast