Re: A silly fact about an atomic clock that relativist never want you to know.

PD wrote:
No, you're right. A straight beampipe starts at one elevation and goes
to a different one. But you missed what I just said. Particles going
through the same beampipe at *different* speeds get *different* time
dilations, even though they are going through the *same* variation in
the gravitational field.

The variation in the differential changes would of course make
different changes in any clock doing such speeds.


Please understand cause and effect. If you
have two objects that exhibit DIFFERENT effects and they are subject
to the SAME influence, then the influence cannot possibly be the cause
of the effect.

Different speeds, is not the "same influence" PD.


Then you'll have to explain why traveling through the SAME beampipe,
through the SAME variation in gravitational field, can produce
DIFFERENT time dilations.

Different speeds are not the "same variation change"
And even relativity gets that right most of the time.
Usually refered to as "relative" mass.
A 1 kg mass moving at 20 meters per second has a different
relative mass than a 1 kg mass moving at any different speed
than 20 meters per second.
Therefore, you do not have the "same" relative mass at all
when you have different speeds at all.
C,mon PD, that is relativity 101.
(some of the actually correct stuff in relativity)
:)
--
James M Driscoll Jr
Spaceman


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Photon, Momentum, Mass
    ... say the same laws of physics apply in all inertial frames of referenec (ie ... "Waldron developed a ballistic theory of light on his own before learning that Walter Ritz had already done it at about the time that Einstein developed his 'Special Relativity'. ... The idea of light separating from the source at different speeds in different FoR is what causes Doppler shift in SR. ... He writes "If a body takes up an amount of energy E then its inertial mass ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: A question about physicists and Einsteins SR Theory
    ... With the corrected mass law as proposed by Lorentz ... > need for different speeds and even if my speculation is wide of the mark ... Relativity works - but no one has tried the alternative to ... Indeed the kind of ether that some proposed in defiance of Newton was again ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: A silly fact about an atomic clock that relativist never want you to know.
    ... The variation in the differential changes would of course make ... Different speeds, is not the "same influence" PD. ... DIFFERENT time dilations. ... And even relativity gets that right most of the time. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Do evolutionists have the answers? (dont be silly)
    ... If by SR you mean Special Relativity, then yes, it's very relevant. ... speeds are discussed (say, when a rocket expels half of its mass as high ... there is no reason to presume that the proton has accelerated at ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Do evolutionists have the answers? (dont be silly)
    ... The Special Theory of Relativity describes certain properties of objects at high constant speed *regardless* of how that speed is achieved. ... Its calculations should be taken into account in any situation where such speeds are discussed (say, when a rocket expels half of its mass as high energy photons in a single direction). ... there is no reason to presume that the proton has accelerated at all. ...
    (talk.origins)