Re: Is there length contraction in SRT, uncle Ben?

xray4abc <lemhenyil@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message
d7011b9a-ab2f-4f9f-9726-a1aa4492db5a@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
On Jul 30, 5:14 pm, "Dirk Van de moortel" <dirkvandemoor...@ThankS-NO-
SperM.hotmail.com> wrote:
xray4abc <lemhen...@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message

598941e5-830f-4dbe-bd43-b1956d920...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx





On Jul 30, 1:00 pm, "Dirk Van de moortel" <dirkvandemoor...@ThankS-NO-
SperM.hotmail.com> wrote:
xray4abc <lemhen...@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message

752648d3-463a-41cf-87b5-cbb98d291...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

On Jul 30, 5:06 am, "Dirk Van de moortel" <dirkvandemoor...@ThankS-NO-
SperM.hotmail.com> wrote:
xray4abc <lemhen...@xxxxxxxx> wrote in message

cfdeda6f-9219-4338-9a08-13086221f...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

What SRT does say about length contraction?
Consider a rod along OX axis be resting in IRF K and
moving in frame K’.
Consider 2 observers in the 2 frames, measuring the
length of the rod, setting up measurements at their will,
where they localize the endpoints in a simultaneous
manner, each in his frame.

In frame K :
Measured values are: X1, X2 in moments T1=T2
Calculated values, from Lorentz transformations are
X’1 and X’2
which give L’=L* Gamma
where L’ is the calculated length for K’
and L is the measured (and at the same time the proper) length
of the object in frame K.
As Gamma>1
We get L’>L that is : the length attributed to be valid
for frame K’ (the moving frame) IS BIGGER than the measured length
(that is the proper length)
( So far nothing new!)

Alas, you are completely wrong here.

If the rod is at rest in K (T1=T2), then it is not at rest in K',
so the value L’=L* Gamma is not the calculated length for
K’ since the times of measurement not the same and the
rod is *moving* in K'.

Then, what is it L'=L*Gamma by your opinion?
One uses simultaneous marking of the endpoints of the rod
no matter in which frame he is in.

When the thing is moving, you must use simultaneous measurements
to be able to substract the distances and call it the "measured length".
When it is not moving, it doesn't matter whether the measurements
are simultaneous to substract the distances and call it the "proper length".

When you understand that, we can continue.
Do you understand that?

Dirk Vdm- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

Yes, sir!
Regards, LL

Okay, so I guess you understand that for an object at rest
in K (with proper length L), the quantity L' = L * Gamma
is as good as useless? It is the difference between the
distances of the *moving* object's end points marked at
different times :-)

Dirk Vdm- Hide quoted text -

- Show quoted text -

I knew exactly what L' was in the above relation.

Yes, a useless quantity.
Measure the distance to the front of moving train now.
Measure the distance to the back of the train 15 minutes later.
Calculate the difference.
Do go yet a meaningful quantity?

Are you suggesting that you can get the relation between the
*measured* value in frame K and the *measured* value in frame K'
for the rod at rest in frame K?
If yes, how you do it?

If the rod is at rest in frame K (with proper lenght Dx), it does
not matter whether the measuments to front and back are taken
simultaneously (i.o.w. Dt does not matter), but you must make
sure they are simultaneous in frame K', i.o.w. make sure Dt' = 0.
Then you can calculate Dx', the *measured* value in frame K'.

You take the transformation equations:
Dx' = g ( Dx - v Dt ) [1]
Dt' = g ( Dt - v Dx /c^2 ) [2]
with
g = 1/sqrt(1-v^2/c^2)
and of course the inverse
Dx = g ( Dx' + v Dt' ) [3]
Dt = g ( Dt' + v Dx' /c^2 ) [4]
together with the condition
Dt' = 0 [5]

The easiest way to go about is by combining [3] and [5] to get
Dx' = 1/g Dx

Another way is to first combine [2] and [5] to get
Dt = v Dx /c^2 [6]
and combine this [6] with [1] to get
Dx' = g ( Dx - v^2 Dx /c^2 )
= g ( 1 - v^2/c^2 ) Dx
= 1/g Dx

Dx is the mearured length in the rest frame K (aka the proper length).
Dx' is the mearured length in a frame K' (aka the coordinate length).
Coordinate lenght is shorter than proper lenght.

Dirk Vdm

.

Relevant Pages