GR [+ Spin] as Poincare' Gauge Theory (was: Gauge Bosons and Metrics)

whopkins_at_csd.uwm.edu
Date: 03/06/05


Date: Sun, 6 Mar 2005 07:52:03 +0000 (UTC)

lost.and.lonely.physicist@gmail.com wrote:
> I understand that the gauge field for U[1] has only 1 index, whereas
> the Christoffel symbol in GR has 3. The gauge field for SU[3] and
SU[2]
> has 2 indices, one for mu, one for summing over the generators, so
they
> don't seem to have enough either.

Going further with my previous reply:

the indices on the general connection A_m^a are a spacetime index (m)
and a Lie index (a). So, for U(1), since (a) only ranges over one
index value it's omitted, and only only talks about an A_m.

This has the unfortunate effect of suppressing the hidden metric and
the raising and lowering of indices:
                     F^{mn}_{.} <--> {D/c, H/c)
                     F_{mn}^{.} <--> (E, B)
with
           F^{mn}_{.} = k_{..} g^{mp} g^{nq} F^{.}_{pq}
The metric coefficient k_{..} is just (epsilon_0 c).

For the Riemannian connection, the indices are actually 2, not 3:
                 Gamma_{mn}^p <--> Gamma_m^{n/p}
with {n/p} the index of GL(4):
    [L^n_m,L^q_p] = delta^n_p e^q_m - delta^q_m e^n_p

In this light, the Cartan structure equations for
        Omega^n_p = Gamma_{mp}^n e^m
        Tau^m = 1/2 Tau^m_{np} e^n ^ e^p = Torsion
        Theta^m_n = 1/2 R^m_{npq} e^p ^ e^q = Riemmannian Curvature
which are, for a general frame (e^1,e^2,...):
                d(e^m) + Omega^m_n ^ e^n = Tau^m
                d(Omega^m_n) + Omega^m_p ^ Omega^p_n = Theta^m_n
suddenly appear in a new light. They're just the equations for a FIELD
STRENGTH
          F = dA + 1/2 [A,A]
          F^c_{mn} = d_m A^c_n - d_n A^c_m + f^c_{ab} A^a_m A^b_n
(expressed in terms of the structure coefficients
                        [Y_a,Y_b] = f^c_{ab} Y_c
for a Lie algebra basis (Y_1,Y_2,...)).

But the operator is not for the gauge group GL(4). It's for the
INHOMOGENEOUS gauge group IGL(4), which extends GL(4) by adding
generators for the translations (P_a, a=1,...,4):
               [P_a,P_b] = 0
               [P_a,L^c_d] = delta^c_a P_d
The gauge field is just the frame, itself, along with the connection
forms:
             A = e^a P_a + Omega^a_b L^b_a.
The corresponding field strength, F, (may have to check for signs)
comes straight out of this:
             F = Tau^a P_a + Theta^a_b L^b_a.
Torsion is the part of the field strength associated with translational
degrees of freedom; the Riemannian curvature that associated with
rotational degrees.

General Relativity is, thus, a gauge theory for IGL(3,1).

The corresponding currents would be:
               p_a -- momentum, coupling to Tau^a
               s^b_a -- spin, coupling to Theta^a_b.

If one wanted, instead, a gauge theory for the Lorentz group SL(3,1)
and its inhomogeneous extension ISL(3,1), the Poincare' group, then the
frames would be restricted to [Minkowski] orthonormal forms:
              g^{mn} e^a_m e^b_n = eta^{ab} = diag(+,-,-,-).

Then everything follows through as above. The corresponding connection
-- called a spin connection -- consists simply of the covariant
derivatives of the e's:
             Omega_m^a_b = d_b(e^a_m) - Gamma^p_{mn} e^b_p e^a_n

and the total gauge field is:
         A = (e^a P_a + Omega^a_b L^b_a)
with field strength:
         F = (Tau^a P_a + Theta^a_b L^b_a)
as before.

This additional structure is equivalent to providing a spin bundle on
the manifold.

If, further, one started out *only* with the gauge field:
                    A = (e^a_m P_a + Omega_m^a_b L^b_a) dx^m
is, and then DEFINED the metric as
                 g_{mn} = eta_{ab} e^a_m e^b_n
and the result would be a complete recovery of the Riemannian curvature
and torsion through the correspondences:
                   Tau^m_{np} e^a_m = Tau^a_{np}
                   R^m_{npq} e^a_m = e^b_n R^a_b_{pq}
showing that the key objects of GR come out for free from the gauge
field and field strength of a Poincare' gauge theory.



Relevant Pages

  • Gravity as a Goldstone-Higgs field, instead of a Gauge Field
    ... When The Pundits talk about "gauge invariance" in GR they do not mean ... The concept of gravity as a Poincare' gauge field is problematic, ... In the context of Lorentz symmetry, ... An ordinary connection resides within the ...
    (sci.physics.research)
  • categorified gauge theory
    ... The problem of defining higher gauge fields is an old one. ... globally by a connection on a "Ugerbe". ... more general Lie groups - particularly *nonabelian* groups. ... I have developed such a theory by systematically categorifying ...
    (sci.math.research)
  • The Loop & Path Representation of Gauge & String Theories (was: Differing views on quantum g
    ... there already is a loop representation for gauge theory ... to incorporate and work out the loop representation of that. ... the path groupoid of the base manifold to the gauge groupoid of the ... This is what provides the representation of the connection ...
    (sci.physics.research)
  • Re: Gauge Transformations in Momentum Space?
    ... Negative-energy gauge transformations, ... Hilbert space is spanned by canonical variables E_uand A_v, ... the negative-energy part of the constraints ... If the renormalized generators were operators, ...
    (sci.physics.research)
  • Re: Kawasaki Fuel Gauge Fault
    ... The fuel gauge has packed up - not really a problem but I can't identify ... The sender works within spec. ... The Bk/Y connection on the loom side is 0v and the W/Y connection is 5v. ...
    (uk.rec.motorcycles)