Re: Little's high temp supercon - numbers
- From: "Thomas Johnson" <thomas_johnson00@xxxxxxxxxxx>
- Date: Thu, 27 Apr 2006 21:19:27 +0000 (UTC)
Uncle Al wrote:
sr wrote:
Uncle Al wrote:
> Let's spend some money synthesizing more
> elegant, more specific solutions to the
> problem. [...]
Speaking of lab work, did you ever post the
final results of your chiral eotvos experiments
here on spr? I don't recall seeing them. (?)
I've posted it multiply. Jun Luo did the first hemiparity Eotvos
experiment, space group P3(2)21 quartz vs. fused silica. He reported
on progress weekly. After 12 weeks he got a dirty null - not zero net
signal but not statistically significant.
A left foot is well-fitted by a sock or a left shoe. Only a right
shoe is anomalous. P3(1)21 quartz must then be the boojum, or nothing
at all.
Jun Luo began the full parity Eotvos experiment, P3(2)21 quartz vs.
P3(1)21 quartz. I recieved 6 weeks of reports, then silence. Neither
I nor Petitjean got replies. I finally retained a degreed native
Mandarin speaker to go after Luo's grad students by telephone.
Petitjean and I finally received an e-mail from a Luo subordinate:
1) It was a Chinese idea and a Chinese experiment
2) The full parity Eotvos experiment was never performed.
3) We could all go piss up a rope.
4) No further communications would be forthcoming.
Perhaps I misinterpreted your post to sci.physics?
http://groups.google.com/group/sci.physics/msg/4b3b8c29df8db6d2?dmode=source&hl=en
As to (1) You posted that Prof. Luo stated:
"We admit that you first bring forward the idea about the possible
violation of the parity Eotvos experiment and we believe nobody denies
it, but the practical experiment is another thing completely."
This does not sound like they claim it to be a "Chinese idea".
As to (2)
In that post, you stated that
"The Luo group reports that they didn't perform the full parity Eotvos
experiment past 10^(-10) difference/average signal, for which they
have already sent me interim results to 10^(-11) difference/average. "
Which sounds to me like they ran the experiment at least partially.
Thomas.
.
- References:
- Little's high temp supercon - numbers
- From: Uncle Al
- Little's high temp supercon - numbers
- Prev by Date: Re: Fun problem
- Next by Date: Gauge fixing question
- Previous by thread: Re: Little's high temp supercon - numbers
- Next by thread: Solutions to Wald's General Relativity problems
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|
|
