point charge problem



The concept of a point charge is well known to have some problems.
Suppose we consider a point charge to be really a spherically
symmetric charge distribution of radius r equal to epsilon with
epsilon having the property that epsilon squared is greater than zero
and and any higher power of epsilon is equal to zero.
This would seem to describe a sphere that is not the boundary of a
ball since it encloses no volume.
Aside from the fact that this sounds weird, can anyone explain to me
what kind of difficulties this approach to the point charge problem
has that other approaches don't? Conversely, it does seem to address
at least the problem that a volume (or surface) integral containing
this object would yield a finite charge even though right at the
location of the charge the density would be infinite (since the volume
at the location of the charge is zero), or am I mistaken?

Thanks,

Armin

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Why do permitivity and permiability appear in EM expressions?
    ... H fields are those PRODUCED by the charge and current sources; ... The "constants" epsilon and mu are only asymptotically so. ... differential geometry, the type of object which converts between ... For electroweak, the metric would be that for the gauge group U ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: point charge problem
    ... Suppose we consider a point charge to be really a spherically ... epsilon having the property that epsilon squared is greater than zero ... and and any higher power of epsilon is equal to zero. ... infinitesimal numbers is called nonstandard analysis - all significant results of interest for physics proved with nonstandard analysis ...
    (sci.physics.research)
  • Re: point charge problem
    ... Suppose we consider a point charge to be really a spherically ... epsilon having the property that epsilon squared is greater than zero ... and and any higher power of epsilon is equal to zero. ...
    (sci.physics.research)
  • Re: Zero Ohms = Mathematically Incorrect
    ... Strictly speaking, current doesn't flow through it, charge does. ... If the resistance is zero, then the amperage is something that math ... Let's look at the case of a superconducting ring in which one ...
    (sci.electronics.basics)
  • Re: Zero Ohms = Mathematically Incorrect
    ... division by zero can usually be solved as a limit. ... Let's say, however, you measure the voltage across one half the conductor. ... The key to understanding this is that the zero ohms is not the entire circuit resistance ... ... Strictly speaking, current doesn't flow through it, charge does. ...
    (sci.electronics.basics)