Re: Big Bang Busted in Science Classes for High Schools

From: Shrikantha S. Shastry (shrikanthas_at_yahoo.com)
Date: 06/07/04 

Date: 6 Jun 2004 22:34:55 -0700

nightbat <nightbat@home.ffni.com> wrote in message news:<40C0220C.9F8108F8@home.ffni.com>...
> nightbat wrote
>
> "Shrikantha S. Shastry" wrote:
>
> > And so, wave particle duality of energy even as observed by you makes
> > it observer dependent. This observer dependent nature of energy makes
> > it illusory. After all, illusion needs its observers. What is an
> > illusion without an observer? As such, all observed phenomena are
> > illusory.
> >
> > On the contrary, the unobserved singularity is real which alone is the
> > origin for the whole illusory observers' universe.
> >
> > S S Shastry
>
> nightbat
>
> Ha, ha, I predicted your continued mixed up null understandings
> despite any of my proper citations and presented resolution and
> clarifications. Shastry sadly, there is no apparent hope for you, for
> you twist much of what is told to you back to your null self notions.
> The Universe is not subject to observer dependency as previously
> advised. It is your illusion that it is and no amount of dialog in
> counter evidence will ultimately satisfy or correct your mixed up
> attributes, clueless bewilderment, and fixation on singularity.
>
>
> the nightbat

nightbat, singularity is singular, and so, includes us within its
universe. As such, singularity is not available outside us as you have
been explaining it away outside you within the universe as in the
present day physics. This limiting explanation of singularity is
simplistic at best and misleading at worst.

S S Shastry

Relevant Pages

  • Re: A partial black hole?
    ... If you're falling into ... Singularity A, can your course be shaped to fall into Sing B? ... From the frame of a hypothetical observer at the singularity, things get infinitely blueshifted, but then again, there can be no such observer. ... even once inside the event horizon. ...
    (rec.arts.sf.science)
  • Re: Big Bang Busted in Science Classes for High Schools
    ... > nightbat wrote ... This observer dependent nature of energy makes ... > attributes, clueless bewilderment, and fixation on singularity. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: error in mathematics behind black holes
    ... -- the singularity at r=2M is in the COORDINATES, ... This is, after all, how physics is done for situations like this -- this manifold is a highly idealized case that is incompatible with the word we inhabit. ... But an observer in the manifold can indeed study that region, as long as she is willing to fall into the black hole. ... Yes, a distant observer cannot _observe_ the interior of the horizon, but that has no bearing on the question of whether or not that region _exists_. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: error in mathematics behind black holes
    ... an observer near the event horizon experiences. ... observer in the frame. ... already said that singularity is "there" for some observers but is not ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: error in mathematics behind black holes
    ... The singularity at r=0 is in the manifold. ... manifold because the locus is singular. ... Some people think that a Schwarzschild observer could study the region ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)