[OT] threading (was: The ultimate luxury ?)

From: Jeff Relf (Jeff_Relf__at__NCPlus.NET.Invalid)
Date: 07/31/04


Date: 31 Jul 2004 00:48:47 GMT

Hi Johan Lindquist,

RFC 1036 ( and plain good manners ) dictate that
  titles should reveal the content of the message.

And, because the parents are still in the References line
  ( or should be ) a good newsreader can still
  navigate to the parents despite the different titles.
  ( Note: Google is not a good newsreader )

Also, I would never place a Followup-To: line in the headers,
  like you just did,
  because it cuts people off from the conversation.
  ( But lets not argue about that,
    a good newsreader would let one ignore that )

Notice that I used the phrase
  " A Good Newsreader " three times,

  That's why I'm writing my own newsreader ( called X ).

  And " operator error " is also a major factor here.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Preaching or Teaching?
    ... themselves and affraid to hear any contrary opinion. ... My newsreader doesn't have a mind reading option, ... against his parents views until he has left home. ...
    (soc.retirement)
  • Re: OT: May I be your dowager? (Martians)
    ... of yours and tell me why the hell they lack any references and appear to ... those of us who have a newsreader capable of starting a new ... Usenet threading is defined by followups, represented by references, ... Saint Bertille Herb Soup ...
    (rec.food.cooking)
  • Re: [slrn] Scoring and headers stripped of tags.
    ... > Is there for slrn any possibility to score entire threads, ... > stripped of that tag by a newsreader (at least that's the impression I'm ... original posting ('base' posting, i.e. one which does not have a ... References: header), then it should work (assuming all replying ...
    (news.software.readers)
  • Re: Posting & Threads (Ongoing conversations)
    ... And if the newsreader you read news with isn't ... You should be sorting by References. ... Here's how the References header works. ... is gone you lose what the response is actually in response to. ...
    (rec.sport.paintball)
  • Re: Fetching a thread
    ... [about a newsreader finding the parent to the current ... "References" line, but is that really what your reader does? ... out which reference is the Message-ID of the parent, ... This even works (if my server has the ...
    (alt.usage.english)