Re: There is no gap between philosophy and physics - is belief evil?

From: Robert J. Kolker (robert_kolker_at_hotmail.com)
Date: 07/14/04


Date: Wed, 14 Jul 2004 13:55:42 GMT


jmfbahciv@aol.com wrote:

>
> Pulleys aren't "commonsense".

Pulleys are "in scale". Moving the Moon with a lever is out of scale
(and impossible).

>
>
>>..That is why early physics
>>was so inaccurate, it could not get to large scale and small scale
>
> reality.
>
> Ooohhh...You're talking about precision. I'd never place precision
> as a non-commonsense aspect.

No. I am talking about just plain wrong. See Aristotle -Physics- and -On
the Heavens-. Aristotle is physics for the unsophisticated. It is the
view of the world held by a child. Piaget would have a good time with
Aristotelean physics. In fact he did.

Modern physics deals with entities which can never be perceived (e.g.
atoms). Why? Either they are hypothetical and do not really exist or
they do exist, but our sensory apparatus is totally unequal to the task
of seeing them.

Bob Kolker



Relevant Pages

  • Re: new here, my lang project... PT2
    ... The scale is limited by the resolution of ... I see this as a precision vs. accuracy issue. ... > physics core ... > just I am not sure how necessary the partitioning is at present. ...
    (comp.object)
  • Re: IS TIME REAL?
    ... >>| place to place in the universe. ... >>physics is very much concerned with such things, ... Because it's not a true spacial dimension. ... > arbitrary scale that we have universally accepted. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: A question on action and tension
    ... he's clinging to physics as far ... He agrees that a longer string needs greater tension to pull it up to ... experience of anyone who has set up a great number of guitars. ... short scale instruments, precisely because the looser string has greater ...
    (rec.music.classical.guitar)
  • Re: A question on action and tension
    ... he's clinging to physics as far ... He agrees that a longer string needs greater tension to pull it up to ... experience of anyone who has set up a great number of guitars. ... short scale instruments, precisely because the looser string has greater ...
    (rec.music.classical.guitar)
  • Pioneer 10/11 Space Probe Anomaly
    ... BTW See Frank Wilczek's latest Op Ed on F = ma in Oct 2004 Physics Today ... Galactic Halo on a larger scale. ...
    (sci.physics)