Re: Speed of Light

From: Bjoern Feuerbacher (feuerbac_at_thphys.uni-heidelberg.de)
Date: 07/16/04


Date: Fri, 16 Jul 2004 10:10:23 +0200

Turtle22 wrote:
>>Uncle Alwrote:
>
>
>>Idiot. Learn the difference between the four-vector and rest
>>mass.
>>
>
>
> Alright now, c'mon. Right now I'm 18 years old, I came up with this
> theory when I was 17 during my AP Chemistry class. I was bored, and
> we've never even learned about four-vector and rest mass. My god man,
> ease up some.

Perhaps you should have told your age and your level of education
before - I think then many people wouldn't have been so harsh to you. ;-)

> As for everyone else, thanks for the input, I've actually learned a
> little about all of this stuff. I've haven't been introduced to
> photons yet and this will probably help me when I do get started on
> them.
>
> As for orignal question, I understand that light doesn't have mass (I
> guess), but I want to know where my formula went wrong.

You formula went wrong because the "m" in E=mc^2 is *not* the thing
which is commonly called "mass" in physics today.

> If my formula
> doesn't have a mistake, then apparently there's a mistake in one of
> the equations.

The "mistake" is in popular science. The equation E=mc^2 is presented
without often without any explaining remarks - when it is applicable,
what the "m" in it means etc.

> And if that's the case then I'd like to look into that
> a little more.

Have you looked at the web page I gave you a link to?

[snip]

Bye,
Bjoern



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Speed of Light
    ... Alright now, c'mon. ... we've never even learned about four-vector and rest mass. ... photons yet and this will probably help me when I do get started on ... doesn't have a mistake, then apparently there's a mistake in one of ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: How can photons be massless
    ... > picture of how clueless Porat is, and how little he understands science. ... therefore should have only mass units at the right side ... and it should not be dependant on any unit system you use ... there is a mistake on your way. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Ancient Magma Superpiles May Have Shaped The Continents
    ... They are so filled with so many logical fallacies that ... You made the claim (mass of Earth changes and so does the moon's). ... is not a claim, you idiot, it is an answer and is its own proof, you ... think of me and that that is why you made the mistake, ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Shes lame. Sigh. Any suggestions before I call the vet?
    ... My mistake. ... But still, lucky you. ... My family moved to Seattle from Mass. ...
    (rec.equestrian)
  • Re: not feeling good about this one.....
    ... but I am not alright with this. ... to reek of the sense of entitlement of Wall Street types that got ... To make that mistake and 'claim' it was a mistake - one should ...
    (rec.outdoors.fishing.fly)