Re: What before big bang?

From: Igor/Grichka (riemannian-cosmology_at_phys-maths.edu.lv)
Date: 09/09/04 

Date: 9 Sep 2004 04:07:46 -0700

YBM <ybmess@nooos.fr> wrote in message news:<413f1dc2$0$29469$636a15ce@news.free.fr>...
> Arkadiusz Jadczyk a écrit :
> >>Arkadiusz Jadczyk a écrit :
> >>
> >>>Why not "the Bogdanovs do really not understand what they talk about"
> >>>but nevertheless some scientists can make sense of what they talk about?
> >>
> >>Is it your new official, as director of the International Institute
> >>of Mathematical Physics (http://th-phys.edu.hk/), position on this
> >>subject ?
>
>
> > You see, you have very poor understanding (or no understanding
> > whatsoever) of progress in science is being made. Take these examples:
>
>
> So I have a "very poor or no" understanding of progress in science
> because I quoted *you* and wrote how much I appreciate *your* comment ?
> I don't really see your point here...
>
> BTW, I guess that a man who is talking on a daily basis with people from
> the future on a ouija board should have impressive insights about "the
> progress of science".

I suggest you accept the main principle on which science is based :
the respect of someone's work which obviously goes beyond your "range
of comprehension". After all Jadczyk has rewritten the mathematical
basis of Witten's ideas to make them readable and acceptable. After
all, Jadcyck wrote critical papers on KMS states and quantum dynamics.
   Did you do the same work? The answer is no. Therefore, please,
be a bit respectfull of real scientific work (even if you pretend than
our work is not "really scientific").

Relevant Pages

  • Re: What before big bang?
    ... > Arkadiusz Jadczyk a écrit: ... I guess that a man who is talking on a daily basis with people from ... I suggest you accept the main principle on which science is based: ... be a bit respectfull of real scientific work (even if you pretend than ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: What before big bang?
    ... Arkadiusz Jadczyk a écrit: ... >>BTW, I guess that a man who is talking on a daily basis with people from ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: What before big bang?
    ... Arkadiusz Jadczyk a écrit: ... >>BTW, I guess that a man who is talking on a daily basis with people from ...
    (sci.physics)