Re: Lorentz transformations - a derivation

From: Tom Capizzi (tom.capizzi_at_verizon.net)
Date: 01/11/05 

Date: Tue, 11 Jan 2005 03:24:26 GMT

"Ken S. Tucker" <dynamics@vianet.on.ca> wrote in message
news:1105380479.824927.275720@c13g2000cwb.googlegroups.com...
> Bill, the reason I jumped on you is because
> of your suggestion for using an accelometer
> reading of zero to define an inertial CS,
> and that suggestion I found to be a good one
> at first glance. However, I gained a better
> understanding of the problem by taking a second
> look, something usually required in GR.
>
> One can easily create a scenario with two
> weightless (free-fall) spacetime coincident
> FoR's that are relatively accelerating,
> satellites in differing orbits for example.
>
> In GR that occurs when the classical G_uv=0,
> but the Riemann-Christoffel B^a_bcd =/=0.
> (I ref'd to AE's GR1916 Eq.(43)...)
>
> The LT and SR does not apply between relatively
> accelerating FoR's, inspite of each being
> inertial, is what I garnered from your suggestion,
> in a fairly clear way...that's a compliment.
>
> So after the detour we return to B^a_bcd =0
> required for LT and SR.
>
> Regards
> Ken S. Tucker
>

Is it even appropriate to call the coordinate system of
a satellite inertial, even though it's in free fall and has
an accelerometer reading of zero? After all, it is still
constantly changing direction, even in a circular orbit
at constant speed. Isn't it still an accelerated coordinate
system?

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Lorentz transformations - a derivation
    ... > reading of zero to define an inertial CS, ... > and that suggestion I found to be a good one ... > accelerating FoR's, inspite of each being ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Combining Fields From Files Without COBOL Pgm?
    ... >>You didn't exactly say whether the longer file contains the same data as ... >>the shorter file. ... >>short records, ignore my suggestion. ... >I will give your suggestion as much attention as the reading which gave ...
    (comp.lang.cobol)
  • Re: Good Books
    ... I finally got it from the library and in the midst of work woes and holiday frazzle, sat down, read the book, and laughed aloud until the last chapter. ... So, all this time later, thanks for the suggestion, and it's worth a read for those who enjoy a good "fish out of water" tale. ... So I'm kind of glad to hear that it was probably just my reading the second time - I was starting to regret that I had recommended it. ...
    (rec.pets.dogs.behavior)
  • Re: A good C Programming book.
    ... Hello there, being a newbie to C and the forum, I've been reading these post ... and have another suggestion for you. ... The C programming vids are extremely useful, ... > a point with GNU/Linux. ...
    (comp.lang.c)
  • Word should open docs with the same formatting as they were saved
    ... Word 2003 has introduced the "reading view", which is the default format when ... formatting and pagination in reading view, in some cases looking worse than ... This post is a suggestion for Microsoft, ...
    (microsoft.public.word.pagelayout)