Re: scholar.google.com

From: Timo Nieminen (uqtniemi_at_mailbox.uq.edu.au)
Date: 01/15/05


Date: Sat, 15 Jan 2005 13:45:43 +1000

On Sat, 15 Jan 2005, Gregory L. Hansen wrote:

> I'd have thought it was an all-or-nothing, either you're payed up
> for the year or you're not sort of thing, but it's apparantly an
> electronic version of having bought a book to keep on your shelves or not.

The former might be OK as an addition to a subsription to the paper
journal, but it's really lousy as a substitute for a paper journal.
Imagine if the library had to keep paying subscription fees every year,
increased at the discretion of the publisher, in order to keep their
back-issues. Pay up or the repo men will visit! The libraries have a
strong case, and even Elsevier must listen. In turn, they say, well, OK,
you can have perpetual access, but you only get what you pay for.

The whole commercial ejournal biz is still experiencing growing pains. So
far, the solutions are not too bad. Libraries still complain about
price-gouging, but less than they did with print journals.

-- 
Timo


Relevant Pages

  • RUTSie Nomination Reminder Thingy Revisitted/Flame of the Year
    ... >>> same online medline journal sources through the online directory ... >> Do you have any idea how much those online medical journals cost ... so I'm well aware of how much trouble libraries are in. ... subscriptions because the cost of subscriptions have skyrocketed. ...
    (rec.sport.football.college)
  • Re: A reasonable argument against double blind tests?
    ... While libraries are passé these days for most people, given the impact of the internet, academic institutions where I worked still have access to databases that can be very helpful. ... Interestingly, none of this kind of training, as well as a typical engineering education at typical universities, will prepare an intrepid buff for the kind of mumbo jumbo situations encountered within the world of audio. ... Many knowledgeable audio designers and journalists are forced by circumstances to play along with the game at least some of the time, because if they do not do so their products will get sub-par reviews in the tweako journals and they might not be able to get a good job if they want to work for a journal. ... The book has over 60 contributors who wrote articles, with most of them being college professors, music-journal editors, or archive librarians. ...
    (rec.audio.opinion)
  • Re: OT Muir journal collection digitized
    ... facilities and equipment to provide online access to the journals at the ... This is where the economics comes in. ... as with all academic/research libraries spends a lot ... that dog won't hunt and until the folks that price this stuff ...
    (rec.outdoors.fishing.fly)
  • Re: PsycLit online?
    ... > Though I assume that APA pays the journals, ... is, somebody pays for the publication cost, which is separate for the cost ...
    (sci.psychology.psychotherapy.moderated)
  • Re: OT Muir journal collection digitized
    ... facilities and equipment to provide online access to the journals at the ... This is where the economics comes in. ... as with all academic/research libraries spends a lot ...
    (rec.outdoors.fishing.fly)