Newton's Cradle with unequal deviding masses

From: mikeboarder (mikeboarder83_at_hotmail.com)
Date: 02/02/05


Date: 2 Feb 2005 14:49:27 -0800

I have a serious problem, i cant stop thinking about it!
if you have a "newton cradle" with for example 9 pendulums. And if
they all have the same mass (Mx), except for the most left one. that
one has a mass My. so that My/Mx is no whole number. e.g. 1,5.
when this one is lifted and collides, two things would be held in mind
i suppose:
the ball hits with velocity v1
1. preservation of momentum.
2. preservation of Energy.
what wil happen at the other end?
when I try to solve=> 1.5*Mx*V1=M*V2
                  and 1.5*Mx*V1^2/2=M*V2^2/2
M stands for the unknown mass that will leave at the right side. for
M=integer*Mx these equasions have no solution. So I made the right end
2 separate balls with mass Mx (of course) and velovity Vs and Vt the
equasions:
1.5*Mx*V1=(Mx*Vs+Mx*Vt) and 1.5*Mx*V1^2/2=(Mx*Vs^2/2+Mx*Vt^2/2)
this gives solutions :
{Vt = 1/2*(3/2+1/2*3^(1/2))*V1, Vs =
1.500000000*V1-.5000000000*(3/2+1/2*3^(1/2))*V1}, {Vt =
1/2*(3/2-1/2*3^(1/2))*V1, Vs =
1.500000000*V1-.5000000000*(3/2-1/2*3^(1/2))*V1}
one of these states that the left one from te two right-end balls is
faster than te most right one=> impossible. => one single solution.
is this the solution? because if you make 3 seperate balls their one
ball could have the speed he wants and the other two shall compensate
to fit the equasions. but certain values would be possible,no?
so how could you know how many pendulums will swing out?
and is my reasoning correct? thanks alot!



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Why no "comb fringes" on VCR still frame?
    ... dropping alternate fields to produce film effect. ... notice the drop in resolution to 288 lines. ... interlace mode and use the other 288 lines, if you wanted, at the ...
    (uk.tech.broadcast)
  • Re: Personhood and nervous systems -- was Re: Pope goes Totalitarian
    ... collapsing what remains of the skull, you are not killing a full, ... perceptive human being. ... Anencephalic foetuses that are born rarely live ... In this case could it be kinder to the parents to allow them that few ...
    (uk.religion.christian)
  • Re: sky reportin ....
    ... Then why is Borrusia Dortmund 10 years ago the last first time winner ... of the European Cup? ... Europe always wins? ...
    (uk.sport.football.clubs.liverpool)
  • Re: Novelty head covers .... camels?
    ... on the course (presumably as an alternative to a buggy) ... We managed to avoid the Defra jobs worths by getting the camel sent in a ... it thus far seems to avoid more than their fair share of bunkers:o) ...
    (uk.sport.golf)
  • Morgan agrees takeover of Wolves
    ... Never trusted his motives, always seemed to be more about him rather than ... Steve Morgan, who twice tried to buy hometown club Liverpool in 2004, is set ...
    (uk.sport.football.clubs.liverpool)