Re: questions - double slit


"dx" <dsflkj@xxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:-_qdnVOtmKBVXg3fRVn-rQ@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>
> "Ron Baker, Pluralitas!" <stoshu@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
> news:473ke.35257$887.3388@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>> ...
>>
>> Note, when you put a detector at a slit you've blocked
>> that slit whether the detector is on or not.
>>
>
> "We would like to think that the particle detectors at the slits are
> affecting the passage of the electron -- perhaps deflecting it, or
> modifying
> it's path, or in some other way influencing the experiment. We could
> accept
> such an explanation. But that does not seem to be the case. A series of
> experiments have been conducted to test just such a hypothesis, and the
> results are uniformly negative."
> http://www.bottomlayer.com/bottom/reality/chap2.html

Rhodes has inappropriately cross applied aspects of entangled
photon experiments to the double slit experiment.
The double slit experiment he describes has never been
done and can never be done. An electron can not pass
through a detector and remain unmodified.

--
rb


.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Is a fact something that has been proven?
    ... see an electron quantum eraser experiment, and that it has a very close ... the double slit is a one electron at a time (i.e. not ... The reason they entangled the photons and electrons is to see if "which ... The detector affects the wave function if it is set up to ULTIMATELY ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: Delayed choice experiment and interstellar signalling
    ... entanglement occurs before the slit. ... a short wave photon is ... but the other, remote detector, can. ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: Pole Barn Paradox - Im *sure* theres a flaw!
    ... Suppose that we put a light detector on the opposite side of the ... In the frame of the slot, ... in the frame of the moving plate, the slot is contracted, so ... Then, in the frame at rest with respect to the slit, there will never be a moment where all the rays are blocked by the lorentz contracted piece of metal. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: questions - double slit
    ... > that slit whether the detector is on or not. ... or in some other way influencing the experiment. ... such an explanation. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Critical size (or Mass?) of the particle at which Macro transitions to Micro (Ref: Double Slit E
    ... one of the slits (either direct / indirect detection of the electron), ... sharpened into the slit where we detected this electron...Till here it ... wave explanation should we identify interference pattern with needles? ... In case of electrons it is understood that a detector presence / ...
    (sci.physics)