Re: why can't fields be quantized too?

flames wrote:

[snip]

Recently it has been demonstrated
by EMSFT for the hydrogen atom
<http://www.unifiedphysics.com/UP_EM_self_fields_all_in_one_revb_Nov_08_04.pdf>
that these E- and H-field form s are not applicable to sub-atomic
charges.

The Maxwell equations (1a) to (1d) on which he bases his whole paper
are already formulated in a wrong way: the charge and current density he uses here make no sense at all. He says that he considers *discrete* particles; this implies that the charge and current densities have to be non-zero only in certain regions of space (for point particles, they have to be sums of delta functions). In contrast, the charge and current densities he uses here are non-zero
*everywhere*, i.e. what he considers is a space filled homogeneously
with charge and current!!!

Wow. This man *really* has no clue of quite elementary electrodynamics.


Bye,
Bjoern
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: maxwells eqns and self-fields
    ... consider *discrete* particles; this implies that the charge and current densities have to be non-zero only in certain regions of space. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: SFT and entanglement
    ... academic acolades, etc; you a young bloke with blood coursing through your viens, me a more sanguine, experienced warrior, but well used to the cut and thrust of scientific debate. ... this implies that the charge and current densities have to be non-zero only in certain regions of space. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: maxwells eqns and self-fields
    ... this implies that the charge and current densities have to be non-zero only in certain regions of space. ... is not "QED data", but simple a relativistic effect; since you claim to incorporate relativity, you should be able to address this ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: SFT is a quantized field, QFT is a classical field
    ... He says that he considers *discrete* particles; this implies that the charge and current densities have to be non-zero only in certain regions of space. ... field form used by QFT as compared with SFT. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: experimental verification of electromagnetic mass
    ... a massless chargeless photon move charged particles? ... >of electrons and positrons that form the shell around the positron. ... That is approximately 2/3rds of the lepton charge has gone ...
    (sci.physics.particle)
Quantcast