Re: Is time dilation real?

"Spaceman" <Realspace@xxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message news:N-udndFX4JcNPUTeRVn-hQ@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>
> "Greg Neill" <gneillREM@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
> news:1YgCf.25047$ve.540398@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
> | As the paradox only exists in your inadequate model,
> | and is completely resolved by relativity, I can
> | sleep well knowing that, unlike you, I don't have to
> | bark at the Moon trying to convince the universe to
> | conform to anachronistic ideas of how it should work.
>
> No,
> the paradox remains with 2 supposed conflicting truths.
> I am using the same model you are using and
> just showing the conflicting facts.
> So my inadequate model as you state, and your model
> are the same models and apparently you can not tell.

Really? Our models are the same? Then you should
have no problem with the Lorentz transforms, and
you should not be saying that there are conflicting
facts since the facts do not conflict when the
model is applied. Somehow I doubt that you and I
are using the same model, since you are denying
that all the facts can be correct.




.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Twin paradox wikipedia version
    ... In the light clock picture, I have no problem with the geometric picture of the light changing from taking the shortest path between the mirrors, to taking a longer path, therefore slowing down. ... A picture of light between mirrors has little to do with twin paradoxes; but all such physics must be well understood before discussing things as twin paradox. ... "If the facts don't fit ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Twin paradox wikipedia version
    ... paradox ignoring this fact. ... of the light changing from taking the shortest path between the mirrors, ... "If the facts don't fit ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Twin paradox wikipedia version
    ... In the light clock picture, I have no problem with the geometric picture of the light changing from taking the shortest path between the mirrors, to taking a longer path, therefore slowing down. ... A picture of light between mirrors has little to do with twin paradoxes; but all such physics must be well understood before discussing things as twin paradox. ... "If the facts don't fit ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Is time dilation real?
    ... | you should not be saying that there are conflicting ... | facts since the facts do not conflict when the ... The Lorentz transforms are not physical proof that the clocks ticked ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Is time dilation real?
    ... > | you should not be saying that there are conflicting ... > | facts since the facts do not conflict when the ... > The Lorentz transforms are not physical proof that the clocks ticked ... > You are to ignorant to find the problem even though ...
    (sci.physics)