Re: Marmet's analysis of Mermin's experiment


srp wrote:
cafeinst@xxxxxxx a écrit :
Does this make article sense?

http://www.newtonphysics.on.ca/Uncertainty/Uncertainty.html

Craig

Marmet was a well known physicist, deeply knowlegeable in
electromagnetism. Passed away June 2005.

If you think settling this question important to you, I suggest
you do like all reasearchers, which is to dig into Maxwell
electromagnetism and Lorentz extension until you can yourself
directly understand the paper and then trust your own judgement
as to its value.

That's why I'm writing here. So I can get the opinions of the experts.
Since I am not an expert, I don't trust my own judgement.

For instance, I read a paper by Herbert Dingle which claimed to refute
Einstein's relativity theory. And I was convinced that he was correct,
but because I knew I am just an amateur, I knew I had to get expert
opinions before making a definite conclusion. So I wrote in here. And
sure enough, I'm now convinced that Einstein was correct and I now have
a deeper appreciation of Einstein's theory of relativity.

So if anybody can provide any insights into Marmet's paper, I would
appreciate this.

Craig


André Michaud

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Marmets analysis of Mermins experiment
    ... electromagnetism and Lorentz extension until you can yourself ... Since I am not an expert, I don't trust my own judgement. ... physicists on this group. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Marmets analysis of Mermins experiment
    ... If you think settling this question important to you, ... you do like all reasearchers, which is to dig into Maxwell ... electromagnetism and Lorentz extension until you can yourself ... directly understand the paper and then trust your own judgement ...
    (sci.physics)