Re: Planck length and black holes

On Mar 7, 11:36 pm, "malibu" <vega...@xxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Mar 7, 11:34 am, "PD" <TheDraperFam...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:



On Mar 7, 2:53 am, "mike3" <mike4...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:

Hi.

I've heard that it is impossible to "confine" a particle to a distance
smaller than one Planck length, since that would cause it to become a
black hole. But wait! A black hole singularity is a place of INFINITE
density, which means it's infinitely SMALLER than a Planck length! So
once you get it into a black hole, it is indeed "confined" to a much
smaller region! Or is it possible that perhaps black holes are _not_
infinitely dense, and this is just a place where current theory fails,
and that they might in reality have only finite (but presumably, huge)
density?

Yes, it is possible. We have no idea what happens inside a black hole
event horizon.

All we know are the following two things:
1. We know of no physical processes that will stop the gravitational
collapse inside the event horizon.
2. We know nothing about what happens at scales comparable to, or
smaller than, the Planck scale.

Any presumed contradictions about what happens *at* the singularity
are purely artifacts of extrapolation beyond what we really know.

PD

you are clueless

Well said, John, full of physics content to mull.
How are your pretty CAD pictures coming? Been able to calculate
anything about neutrinos with them?

PD

.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Planck length and black holes
    ... A black hole singularity is a place of INFINITE ... which means it's infinitely SMALLER than a Planck length! ... collapse inside the event horizon. ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Planck length and black holes
    ... A black hole singularity is a place of INFINITE ... which means it's infinitely SMALLER than a Planck length! ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: Planck length and black holes
    ... I've heard that it is impossible to "confine" a particle to a distance ... A black hole singularity is a place of INFINITE ... which means it's infinitely SMALLER than a Planck length! ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Planck length and black holes
    ... I've heard that it is impossible to "confine" a particle to a distance ... A black hole singularity is a place of INFINITE ... which means it's infinitely SMALLER than a Planck length! ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: PROOF that space-time must be discrete and quantized.
    ... >> such a way that the Planck length is the smallest physically meaningful ... >> In summary I present the theory of quantized space time with all the bells ... >> result of Beckenstien and Hawking with regards to black hole entropy. ... >> assumes the wavelength of photons bound in the black hole is equal to the ...
    (sci.physics)