Re: lorenz transformation



In sci.physics, Chrisd5000rouge
<christian.duez@xxxxxxxxxxx>
wrote
on Wed, 19 Sep 2007 13:19:28 -0700
<1190233168.853738.213500@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>:
Hello,
Can somebody clarify this for me?
if two spacecrafts approach at the speed of v=0.8c and w=0.8c, the
lorenz transformation gives their relative approach speed by u= (v+w)/
(1+vw/c²) = about 0.975c. ok fine, I understand it can not be more
than 1c.
Now let's suppose that they run on opposite directions at those same
speeds, is this relation still valid? If I use the same relation, I
would state v=0.8 and w= -0.8c, but then the result is u=0 ???. How
should it be calculated?


Your coordinate system is slightly confused. One might
use instead the subtraction formula

u = (v-w)/(1-vw/c^2)

for the sake of consistency. That way, spacecraft A could
have velocity 0.8c, and spacecraft B velocity -0.8c --
and they would approach in that case, yielding
u = 1.6 / 1.64 = 40/41 = 0.97561 c.

If both spacecraft have velocity 0.8c, then one gets

(0-0)/(1 - .64) = 0

which is a useful check to at least ensure the signs are close to
correct. ;-)

(Note that it is possible to derive either formula from the Lorentz.)

--
#191, ewill3@xxxxxxxxxxxxx
"Woman? What woman?"

--
Posted via a free Usenet account from http://www.teranews.com

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: We have to respect the limits of human knowledge!
    ... but also about physics. ... The theory of general relativity is nothing to do with the speed of ... of the spacecraft have reached infinity. ... matter into speeds approaching the relativistic speeds region. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: We have to respect the limits of human knowledge!
    ... of the spacecraft have reached infinity. ... travel *slower* than the speed of light, and these particles have been ... tachyons don't exist as discreet particles but as a tachyonic field. ... matter into speeds approaching the relativistic speeds region. ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: We have to respect the limits of human knowledge!
    ... of the spacecraft have reached infinity. ... tachyons don't exist as discreet particles but as a tachyonic field. ... the spaceship and expanding it behind the spaceship. ... tachyonic field forward at speeds exceeding that of light, ...
    (talk.origins)
  • Re: why not this SR experiment?
    ... The same experiment can be done if the spacecraft leaves ... Calculate relative motion of those moons wrt earth. ... Photons that traveled at speeds other than c would throw off the times of ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: lorenz transformation and spped of light
    ... It not a "perception" .. ... Why cannot the reality be that of two spacecrafts running at ... of each spacecraft can compute its absolute ... so there are as many speeds ...
    (sci.physics)