Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: franklinhu@xxxxxxxxx
- Date: Sat, 13 Oct 2007 22:47:44 -0700
I have been reading the original "Does the Inertia of a Body Depend
Upon Its Energy-Content?" 1905 paper by Albert Einstein and I really
don't see how Einstein concluded e=mc^2.
See the original paper at:
http://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/E_mc2/www/
The last part says:
"Neglecting magnitudes of fourth and higher orders we may place
K0-K1 = 1/2(L/c^2)v^2
From this equation it directly follows that:--
If a body gives off the energy L in the form of radiation, its mass
diminishes by L/c²."
Now just how does this in any way directly follow???? He might as well
have said " ... and then a miracle happens and ...".
The equation above doesn't appear to contain any mass parameter. The
K0, K1 terms appear to represent a kinetic energy terms. It appears to
me to be saying that the difference in kinetic energy depends on the
energy L emitted by the system in question.
How do you get E=mc^2 from any of this?
-fhuemc
.
- Follow-Ups:
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: hhc314@xxxxxxxxx
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: Igor
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: Daryl McCullough
- Forget “ mass ” and “ energy ”, all you need to know is this...
- From: Jeff☠Relf
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: CWatters
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: Eric Gisse
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: Pmb
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- From: Henry
- Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- Prev by Date: Re: Invasive, Indeed:
- Next by Date: Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- Previous by thread: Magnetic Fields at general points in space
- Next by thread: Re: Please explain where you get e=mc^2 from 1905 paper
- Index(es):
Relevant Pages
|