Re: Perpetum Mobile Idea

On Mar 18, 10:34 am, "gb6...@xxxxxxxxx" <gb6...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Mar 17, 12:59 pm, "CWatters"





<colin.watt...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:
<gb6...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message

news:76105b62-f7f0-4486-ba81-572ba3dfc306@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

I had this idea a long time ago, found it in my bitmap files,
completely forgot about it,
looked at it and said: It should work.

There can be valves allowing flow one way only (clockwise) or in any
direction without
valves.

http://www.geocities.com/gmbajszar/perp359.JPG

Putting aside COE for a moment...

The extra mass on the right can only cause the large cylinder to rotate IF
the valves between pockets are closed.

Very small openings between pockets still allow the weight to sit and
that
weight pushes down. The water flows slowly between pockets, no valves
are needed. Just the large volume of sitting pressure presses water
(theoretically)
between pockets. The passage on the left is narrow, the weight that
presses on
the much smaller weight on the left has a huge difference.

It can't BOTH flow from A-B AND push the cylinder around.

It is delayed. The weight on the right is huge.

In practise it will turn 90 degrees, oscillate a bit like a pendulum and stop.

It can't move down 90 degrees until water on the left is pressed
through. It
is self slowing.

If the cylinder is held stationary...the water pressure on the left and
right is the same so the water doesn't flow anywhere.

Very large weight on the right slowly squeezes through a much smaller
weight on the left. A large weight can squeeze up a smaller weight
much
higher.

One more to add the the Museum of Unworkable Devices...

http://www.lhup.edu/~dsimanek/museum/unwork.htm

Not yet.

Also the thing wouldn't rotate 90 degrees because the two cylinders
are held by a chain to rotate together by a bycicle chain. The thing
is
held in place.
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Perpetum Mobile Idea
    ... the valves between pockets are closed. ... weight pushes down. ... Just the large volume of sitting pressure presses water ...
    (sci.physics)
  • Re: TA inspired by MP? - spoiler Wednesday
    ... residing in Eddie's pockets? ... hints by him putting on his "false voice" and being somewhat smug or ... The surprise he expressed on learning his weight ... I thought the surprise in his voice when he was weighed was because he ...
    (uk.media.radio.archers)
  • Re: Questions about DIR
    ... This could be an issue with travelling, ... >> Integrated weight BCs are nice but they are not DIR. ... same thing with trim pockets threaded onto my waist belt. ... >> anyhow, negatively buoyant fins such as Jet Fins, which are DIR are ...
    (rec.scuba.equipment)
  • Re: Questions about DIR
    ... >> Metal backplates are heavy. ... This could be an issue with travelling, ... >> BC pockets are nice to have but they're not DIR. ... >> Integrated weight BCs are nice but they are not DIR. ...
    (rec.scuba.equipment)
  • Re: Buoyancy problems at shallow depths
    ... in each pocket in addition to a weight belt, so I guess that could be ... removing the weights is not as quick as just ditching a weight belt by ... belts with integrated BCs. ... of the weight pockets, ...
    (rec.scuba)
Quantcast