Re: diamonds



<hhc314@xxxxxxxxx> wrote in message
news:86969203-8818-4794-b1f5-3ffdf1c4c360@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

Thomas, these are very excellent questions. I suppose that this
question falls into the science of geology, which is a very young
branch of science and appears thus far quite comfortable in revising
their basic theory quite often (often being 20-40 years in this case.)

From my perspective, geologist still assume that all oil, coal, and
diamonds have their basis is once existing organic life, but they fail
to ask the very basic question of where did the carbon required to
form organic life originate here on earth.

The same place all the rest of the elements did, in supernova
explosions. The major elemental abundances in the universe at
large are (source: wikipedia):

Element PPM
---------- -------
Hydrogen 739,000
Helium 240,000
Oxygen 10,700
Carbon 4,600
Neon 1,340
Iron 1,090
Nitrogen 950
Silicon 650
Magnesium 580
Sulfer 440
All Others 650

Earthbound processes merely redistribute and recombine the
given elements (well, radioactivity shifts the concentrations
of some over time).


It's the classic chicken and egg question, and to my limited
knowledge, few researchers have seriously addressed it.

Expand your knowledge! Absence of effort is not the same
as absence of evidence.


Harry C.

p.s., An identical issue exists wih the oil deposits that are
frequently discovered many thousands of feet below the earths
surface. Where did they originate?

Deposition buries layers, oil percolates through porous
regions, collecting in regions surrounded by impermiable
layers. Ponder the possibilites, reach reasonable
conclusions.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Dons blog
    ... of the science they say they support. ... Jo saying there's more to geology than plate tectonics, ... And that means asking questions, ... If that's not a RIGHT UPPEM ABSOLUTE BEAUTY to make them ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: New Insights Into Convection In Planets And Stars
    ... the burning desire to defend a point.I do mind that plate tectonics is ... being diluted by an abysmal 'convection cell' mechanism but there is ... ..but in this case Earth science is blocking the way. ... In geology, surface correlations are facts. ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Re: Wiki article
    ... The matter will rest until I feel it time to bring up again. ... the thermal 'convection cells' remain. ... who subscribe to it by linking astronomy with geology. ... science furnishes it, may modify the conclusions we draw." ...
    (sci.geo.geology)
  • Shell bosss confession shocks industry: Oil chief: my fears for planet
    ... Oil chief: my fears for planet ... Shell boss's 'confession' shocks industry ... the threat of climate change makes him "really very worried for the ... His words follow those of the government's chief science adviser, ...
    (sci.econ)
  • Shell bosss confession shocks industry: Oil chief: my fears for planet
    ... Oil chief: my fears for planet ... Shell boss's 'confession' shocks industry ... the threat of climate change makes him "really very worried for the ... His words follow those of the government's chief science adviser, ...
    (sci.energy.hydrogen)