Re: What is Ether?



On Apr 20, 8:10 pm, "hhc...@xxxxxxxxx" <hhc...@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
On Apr 20, 5:52 pm, af...@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx (John Park) wrote:

Igor (thoov...@xxxxxxxxxx) writes:
Ether is a flammable hydrocarbon gas.

 Liquid or vapour actually, and not strictly hydrocarbon ( C2H5-O-C2H5 ).

        --John Park

No John, the Aether is a solid, since it propagates "transverse
vibrations".  :-)

On a more serious not, has anyone not noticed the the measured
pemittivity and permeability of the Aether is identical to that of a
vacuum?  Perhaps Maxwell was not stupid.

Harry C.

Dear Harry C: Maxwell WAS most stupid. To wit: He figured the ether
that was everywhere could slow light. He proposed that Michelson test
that with his new planar interferometer over a light path of a few
feet (or a thousand; it's the same concept). If a thousand feet of
ether could slow light, think how much light would be slowed in
traveling those many miles from the Sun. Effectively, if ether 'has
drag', the light from the Sun and the stars would never get here, and
there would be no life on Earth. Are you here? Then Maxwell, and
every physicist for the last 121 years, was or is VERY stupid. —
NoEinstein —
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Aether; was Re: Can somebody please help me with understanding this Michelson Morley setup?
    ... aether idea was a stupid one even without Relativity. ... Hence no need for the aether: the light is its own medium. ... Maxwell, pointed out that energy can only be transmitted from one ... So in the case the transmission is by waves, ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Why LET Is Superior to SR!
    ... ANY REFERENCE to where this is shown in the ... >> writing of Maxwell that even suggest this. ... > to back up that Maxwell thought of the kind of ether that he claims, ... about any stationary aether. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Why LET Is Superior to SR!
    ... ANY REFERENCE to where this is shown in the ... >> writing of Maxwell that even suggest this. ... > to back up that Maxwell thought of the kind of ether that he claims, ... about any stationary aether. ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Why LET Is Superior to SR!
    ... >> the existence of the kind of aether that Maxwell thought to exist. ... ANY REFERENCE to where this is shown in the ... back up that Maxwell thought of the kind of ether that he claims, ...
    (sci.physics.relativity)
  • Re: Demolishing the modern synthesis
    ... Lodder) wrote: ... attempts at refuting the demolition and arguments against the ... No one thought of giving up the aether altogether. ... "stationary" ether instead of, simply, ether. ...
    (talk.origins)