Re: Physicist James Van Allen Dies at 91

henry@xxxxxxxxxxxxx (Henry Spencer) wrote:

In article <44dcbe64.2019874718@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>,
Derek Lyons <fairwater@xxxxxxxxx> wrote:
...In lunar science, the results of all the unmanned landers put
together are not much more than footnotes to the Apollo results; the ratio
of results is *much* larger than the ratio of costs.

Of *course* the ration is much larger than the ratio of costs -
because the unmanned programs were largely engineering ones in support
of the manned program.

That would surprise the builders and operators of the Luna sample-return
and rover missions, who most definitely weren't trying to support anyone's
manned program, let alone the *US* one...

I did use the word 'largely' Henry, not 'entirely'. Even if you lump
in the Soviet programs - you still don't get (overall) a serious and
significant program to lay beside and compare on an one on one basis
to the manned one.

<snippage handwaving>

Apples and oranges.

It *is* a problematic comparison. However, it has the enormous virtue of
being real data on real missions built and flown at about the same time
with about the same technology,

<snippage handwaving>

Apples and oranges are real too Henry. That doesn't mean comparisons
between them are valid.

D.
--
Touch-twice life. Eat. Drink. Laugh.

-Resolved: To be more temperate in my postings.
Oct 5th, 2004 JDL
.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Lets see some numbers
    ... numerator and the denominator and you have something to compare them to. ... Mass spec works best when peak heights are compared relative to one another resulting in a ratio, rather than as a quantifying device unless the run is carefully calibrated against standards of known concentration. ... Even the isotope test is a test of ratios, ... I believe the cutoff for endogenous testosterone is anything below 3 parts per million, which is easy to quantify by setting the right Y axis scale. ...
    (rec.bicycles.racing)
  • Re: ABs are crap
    ... However I've not yet sunk to the depths of having to compare how ... If you actually support a good team, ... Seriously though - it's a long way from the probables vs possibles game of a few years back which probably was the best 2 sides in the world at the time. ... It also strikes me that you've not addressed many of the problems Mitchell had since Henry took over, it just looked like you had because a couple of exceptional players carried you through the early Henry days. ...
    (rec.sport.rugby.union)
  • Re: ABs are crap
    ... However I've not yet sunk to the depths of having to compare how ... If you actually support a good team, ... Seriously though - it's a long way from the probables vs possibles game of a few years back which probably was the best 2 sides in the world at the time. ... It also strikes me that you've not addressed many of the problems Mitchell had since Henry took over, it just looked like you had because a couple of exceptional players carried you through the early Henry days. ...
    (rec.sport.rugby.union)
  • Re: So what exactly do scientists know about global warming?
    ... compare the lifestyle of say Henry VIII's wife against that ...
    (uk.business.agriculture)
  • Re: Egyptian Chronology
    ... There is nothing circular about this process. ... Someone finds a piece of wood which, by means of ring counting, the ... wood from 1287 year ring and determine its C12/C14 ratio. ... that measured ratio and compare it with the theoretical ratio from the ...
    (sci.archaeology)
Quantcast