Re: On a Wing and a Catapult

From: Ian Stirling (root_at_mauve.demon.co.uk)
Date: 08/29/04


Date: 29 Aug 2004 13:33:27 GMT

Joann Evans <bondage@frontiernet.net> wrote:
> Steve VanSickle wrote:
>>
>> From article <13fd3446.0408262212.78603d6a@posting.google.com>, by skearney7@earthlink.net (Old Physics):
>>
>> > Rutan's white knight has to have a ground clearence greater than
>> > the height of the rocket it carries and take off requires greater
>> > thrust than climbing to altitude. This looks like a job for a
>> > specialized catapult.
>>
>> How is a mile long catapult any easier, cheaper, or better than just
>> building bigger landing gear?
>
>
> 'Bigger' landing gear is 'heavier' landing gear, is 'occupy more
> internal volume' landing gear. It cuts into payload faster than
> attaching a catapult carrage to hardpoints on the launcher frame, and if
> necessary, lightening the ship by dumping fuel during aborts (also
> desirable for obviuos safety reasons) before landing.
>

In this case, for a nominal mission, the landing gear does not need
to be oversized, just the takeoff gear.

Detatchable takeoff carridge might just work.

You could even have it independantly powered.

Engine failure before launch, or launch failure is now a Bad Day, though,
unless you can safely jettison the rocket.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: On a Wing and a Catapult
    ... >> building bigger landing gear? ... >aircraft, in this weight class, could be designed with landing gear ... Almost certainly it would cost less than the catapult. ... Bear in mind that it doesn't have to be an all-new design. ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: On a Wing and a Catapult
    ... >> specialized catapult. ... internal volume' landing gear. ... attaching a catapult carrage to hardpoints on the launcher frame, ... lightening the ship by dumping fuel during aborts (also ...
    (sci.space.policy)
  • Re: Direct Launch Proposal
    ... Cargo Launch Vehicle with one single "Universal Launcher", ... I find these verticle lift off vehicles appear to be more problems and inheretly dangerous than a posible horizontal lift off vehicle would be. ... But either way, the landing gear must be able to support the gross loft-off weight of the ship, and above a certain point, that particular structure starts eating into payload. ...
    (sci.space.policy)

Quantcast